Two questions about weakly convergent series related to $sin(n^2)$ and Weyl's inequality
up vote
53
down vote
favorite
By using partial summation and Weyl's inequality, it is not hard to show that the series $sum_{ngeq 1}frac{sin(n^2)}{n}$ is convergent.
- Is is true that $$frac{1}{2}=infleft{alphainmathbb{R}^+:sum_{ngeq 1}frac{sin(n^2)}{n^alpha}mbox{ is convergent}right}?$$
- In the case of a positive answer to the previous question, what is $$infleft{betainmathbb{R}^+:sum_{ngeq 1}frac{sin(n^2)}{sqrt{n}(log n)^beta}mbox{ is convergent}right}?$$
real-analysis sequences-and-series number-theory uniform-distribution diophantine-approximation
add a comment |
up vote
53
down vote
favorite
By using partial summation and Weyl's inequality, it is not hard to show that the series $sum_{ngeq 1}frac{sin(n^2)}{n}$ is convergent.
- Is is true that $$frac{1}{2}=infleft{alphainmathbb{R}^+:sum_{ngeq 1}frac{sin(n^2)}{n^alpha}mbox{ is convergent}right}?$$
- In the case of a positive answer to the previous question, what is $$infleft{betainmathbb{R}^+:sum_{ngeq 1}frac{sin(n^2)}{sqrt{n}(log n)^beta}mbox{ is convergent}right}?$$
real-analysis sequences-and-series number-theory uniform-distribution diophantine-approximation
2
By modelling $sin(n^2)$ as a sequence of independent random variables $X_n$, I would expect a positive answer to the first question, also I would expect the later series to be convergent when $beta > 1/2$ and divergent when $beta < 1/2$. Thus the answer to the second question would be $1/2$.
– blabler
Nov 30 '12 at 4:13
A related question has popped up since this one was asked.
– Douglas B. Staple
Mar 29 '13 at 3:44
1
Applying the argument here, math.stackexchange.com/questions/2270/… we obtain that the first quantity is $leq frac{7}{8}$
– i707107
Jun 8 '13 at 17:33
add a comment |
up vote
53
down vote
favorite
up vote
53
down vote
favorite
By using partial summation and Weyl's inequality, it is not hard to show that the series $sum_{ngeq 1}frac{sin(n^2)}{n}$ is convergent.
- Is is true that $$frac{1}{2}=infleft{alphainmathbb{R}^+:sum_{ngeq 1}frac{sin(n^2)}{n^alpha}mbox{ is convergent}right}?$$
- In the case of a positive answer to the previous question, what is $$infleft{betainmathbb{R}^+:sum_{ngeq 1}frac{sin(n^2)}{sqrt{n}(log n)^beta}mbox{ is convergent}right}?$$
real-analysis sequences-and-series number-theory uniform-distribution diophantine-approximation
By using partial summation and Weyl's inequality, it is not hard to show that the series $sum_{ngeq 1}frac{sin(n^2)}{n}$ is convergent.
- Is is true that $$frac{1}{2}=infleft{alphainmathbb{R}^+:sum_{ngeq 1}frac{sin(n^2)}{n^alpha}mbox{ is convergent}right}?$$
- In the case of a positive answer to the previous question, what is $$infleft{betainmathbb{R}^+:sum_{ngeq 1}frac{sin(n^2)}{sqrt{n}(log n)^beta}mbox{ is convergent}right}?$$
real-analysis sequences-and-series number-theory uniform-distribution diophantine-approximation
real-analysis sequences-and-series number-theory uniform-distribution diophantine-approximation
asked Oct 17 '12 at 9:08
Jack D'Aurizio
282k33274653
282k33274653
2
By modelling $sin(n^2)$ as a sequence of independent random variables $X_n$, I would expect a positive answer to the first question, also I would expect the later series to be convergent when $beta > 1/2$ and divergent when $beta < 1/2$. Thus the answer to the second question would be $1/2$.
– blabler
Nov 30 '12 at 4:13
A related question has popped up since this one was asked.
– Douglas B. Staple
Mar 29 '13 at 3:44
1
Applying the argument here, math.stackexchange.com/questions/2270/… we obtain that the first quantity is $leq frac{7}{8}$
– i707107
Jun 8 '13 at 17:33
add a comment |
2
By modelling $sin(n^2)$ as a sequence of independent random variables $X_n$, I would expect a positive answer to the first question, also I would expect the later series to be convergent when $beta > 1/2$ and divergent when $beta < 1/2$. Thus the answer to the second question would be $1/2$.
– blabler
Nov 30 '12 at 4:13
A related question has popped up since this one was asked.
– Douglas B. Staple
Mar 29 '13 at 3:44
1
Applying the argument here, math.stackexchange.com/questions/2270/… we obtain that the first quantity is $leq frac{7}{8}$
– i707107
Jun 8 '13 at 17:33
2
2
By modelling $sin(n^2)$ as a sequence of independent random variables $X_n$, I would expect a positive answer to the first question, also I would expect the later series to be convergent when $beta > 1/2$ and divergent when $beta < 1/2$. Thus the answer to the second question would be $1/2$.
– blabler
Nov 30 '12 at 4:13
By modelling $sin(n^2)$ as a sequence of independent random variables $X_n$, I would expect a positive answer to the first question, also I would expect the later series to be convergent when $beta > 1/2$ and divergent when $beta < 1/2$. Thus the answer to the second question would be $1/2$.
– blabler
Nov 30 '12 at 4:13
A related question has popped up since this one was asked.
– Douglas B. Staple
Mar 29 '13 at 3:44
A related question has popped up since this one was asked.
– Douglas B. Staple
Mar 29 '13 at 3:44
1
1
Applying the argument here, math.stackexchange.com/questions/2270/… we obtain that the first quantity is $leq frac{7}{8}$
– i707107
Jun 8 '13 at 17:33
Applying the argument here, math.stackexchange.com/questions/2270/… we obtain that the first quantity is $leq frac{7}{8}$
– i707107
Jun 8 '13 at 17:33
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
up vote
0
down vote
I recall a generalization of partial summation formula:
Suppose that $lambda_1,lambda_2,ldots$ is a nondecreasing sequence of real numbers with limit infinity, that $c_1,c_2,ldots$ is an arbitrary sequence of real or complex numbers, and that $f(x)$ has a continuous derivative for $xgeq lambda_1$. Put
$$
C(x)=sum_{lambda_nleq x}c_n,
$$
where the summation is over all $n$ for which $lambda_nleq x$. Then for $xgeqlambda_1$,
$$
sum_{lambda_nleq x}c_nf(lambda_n)=C(x)f(x)-int^{x}_{lambda_1}C(t)f'(t)dt.tag 1
$$
Now we can write if $y=x^2$ and $lambda_n=n^2$ and $C(t)=[sqrt{t}]$ (integer part of $sqrt{t}$):
$$
S=sum_{1leq nleq x}frac{sin(n^2)}{n^a}=sum_{lambda_nleq y}frac{sin(lambda_n)}{lambda_n^{a/2}}=
$$
$$
=[sqrt{y}]frac{sin(y)}{y^{a/2}}-int^{y}_{1}[sqrt{t}]frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt.
$$
But it is $[sqrt{t}]=sqrt{t}-{sqrt{t}}$, where ${sqrt{t}}$ is the fractional part of $sqrt{t}$. Hence
$$
S=-frac{1}{2}Releft[iy^{1/2-a/2}Eleft(frac{1+a}{2},iyright)right]+frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]+sin(1)-{sqrt{y}}frac{sin(y)}{y^{a/2}}+int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt,
$$
where
$$
E(a,z)=int^{infty}_{1}frac{e^{-tz}}{t^a}dt
$$
But when $a>0$ and $yrightarrow+infty$ we have
$$
lim_{yrightarrow+infty}left{-frac{1}{2}Releft[iy^{1/2-a/2}Eleft(frac{1+a}{2},iyright)right]+frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]right}+sin(1)=
$$
$$
=frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]+sin(1)
$$
Also $x$ is positive integer and ${sqrt{y}}=0$.
Hence when $a>0$, then
$$
lim_{xrightarrowinfty}sum^{x}_{n=1}frac{sin(n^2)}{n^a}=frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]+sin(1)+lim_{yrightarrowinfty}int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt
$$
But
$$
int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt=int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{cos(t)t^{a/2}-a/2sin(t)t^{a/2-1}}{t^a}dt=
$$
$$
int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}left(cos(t)t^{-a/2}-a/2sin(t)t^{-a/2-1}right)dt=int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{cos(t)}{t^{a/2}}dt-frac{a}{2}int^{y}_{1}frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2+1}}{sqrt{t}}dt.
$$
Clearly
$$
int^{y}_{1}frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2+1}}{sqrt{t}}dt=2int^{x}_{1}frac{sin(t^2)}{t^{a+1}}{t}dt<infty,
$$
for all $a>0$, since $0leq{t}<1$ and $-1leqsin(t^2)leq 1$, for all $t>0$.
Hence it remains to find under what condition on $a>0$ we have
$$
int^{infty}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{cos(t)}{t^{a/2}}dt=2int^{infty}_{1}cos(t^2)t^{1-a}{t}dt<infty,
$$
knowinig already that for all $0<aleq 1$ we have
$$
int^{infty}_{1}cos(t^2)t^{1-a}dt<infty.
$$
When you applied the partial summation, it seems that you used $C(t)=sqrt t$. However, $C(t)=lfloor sqrt t rfloor$.
– i707107
Jun 18 at 22:00
I saw your edit. Then you have to show that the limit as $yrightarrowinfty$ exists. Otherwise, the proof is incomplete.
– i707107
Nov 13 at 22:46
You cannot just ignore ${t}$ at the last step, since $cos(t^2)$ changes sign infinitely often.
– i707107
15 hours ago
add a comment |
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
0
down vote
I recall a generalization of partial summation formula:
Suppose that $lambda_1,lambda_2,ldots$ is a nondecreasing sequence of real numbers with limit infinity, that $c_1,c_2,ldots$ is an arbitrary sequence of real or complex numbers, and that $f(x)$ has a continuous derivative for $xgeq lambda_1$. Put
$$
C(x)=sum_{lambda_nleq x}c_n,
$$
where the summation is over all $n$ for which $lambda_nleq x$. Then for $xgeqlambda_1$,
$$
sum_{lambda_nleq x}c_nf(lambda_n)=C(x)f(x)-int^{x}_{lambda_1}C(t)f'(t)dt.tag 1
$$
Now we can write if $y=x^2$ and $lambda_n=n^2$ and $C(t)=[sqrt{t}]$ (integer part of $sqrt{t}$):
$$
S=sum_{1leq nleq x}frac{sin(n^2)}{n^a}=sum_{lambda_nleq y}frac{sin(lambda_n)}{lambda_n^{a/2}}=
$$
$$
=[sqrt{y}]frac{sin(y)}{y^{a/2}}-int^{y}_{1}[sqrt{t}]frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt.
$$
But it is $[sqrt{t}]=sqrt{t}-{sqrt{t}}$, where ${sqrt{t}}$ is the fractional part of $sqrt{t}$. Hence
$$
S=-frac{1}{2}Releft[iy^{1/2-a/2}Eleft(frac{1+a}{2},iyright)right]+frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]+sin(1)-{sqrt{y}}frac{sin(y)}{y^{a/2}}+int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt,
$$
where
$$
E(a,z)=int^{infty}_{1}frac{e^{-tz}}{t^a}dt
$$
But when $a>0$ and $yrightarrow+infty$ we have
$$
lim_{yrightarrow+infty}left{-frac{1}{2}Releft[iy^{1/2-a/2}Eleft(frac{1+a}{2},iyright)right]+frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]right}+sin(1)=
$$
$$
=frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]+sin(1)
$$
Also $x$ is positive integer and ${sqrt{y}}=0$.
Hence when $a>0$, then
$$
lim_{xrightarrowinfty}sum^{x}_{n=1}frac{sin(n^2)}{n^a}=frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]+sin(1)+lim_{yrightarrowinfty}int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt
$$
But
$$
int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt=int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{cos(t)t^{a/2}-a/2sin(t)t^{a/2-1}}{t^a}dt=
$$
$$
int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}left(cos(t)t^{-a/2}-a/2sin(t)t^{-a/2-1}right)dt=int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{cos(t)}{t^{a/2}}dt-frac{a}{2}int^{y}_{1}frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2+1}}{sqrt{t}}dt.
$$
Clearly
$$
int^{y}_{1}frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2+1}}{sqrt{t}}dt=2int^{x}_{1}frac{sin(t^2)}{t^{a+1}}{t}dt<infty,
$$
for all $a>0$, since $0leq{t}<1$ and $-1leqsin(t^2)leq 1$, for all $t>0$.
Hence it remains to find under what condition on $a>0$ we have
$$
int^{infty}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{cos(t)}{t^{a/2}}dt=2int^{infty}_{1}cos(t^2)t^{1-a}{t}dt<infty,
$$
knowinig already that for all $0<aleq 1$ we have
$$
int^{infty}_{1}cos(t^2)t^{1-a}dt<infty.
$$
When you applied the partial summation, it seems that you used $C(t)=sqrt t$. However, $C(t)=lfloor sqrt t rfloor$.
– i707107
Jun 18 at 22:00
I saw your edit. Then you have to show that the limit as $yrightarrowinfty$ exists. Otherwise, the proof is incomplete.
– i707107
Nov 13 at 22:46
You cannot just ignore ${t}$ at the last step, since $cos(t^2)$ changes sign infinitely often.
– i707107
15 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
I recall a generalization of partial summation formula:
Suppose that $lambda_1,lambda_2,ldots$ is a nondecreasing sequence of real numbers with limit infinity, that $c_1,c_2,ldots$ is an arbitrary sequence of real or complex numbers, and that $f(x)$ has a continuous derivative for $xgeq lambda_1$. Put
$$
C(x)=sum_{lambda_nleq x}c_n,
$$
where the summation is over all $n$ for which $lambda_nleq x$. Then for $xgeqlambda_1$,
$$
sum_{lambda_nleq x}c_nf(lambda_n)=C(x)f(x)-int^{x}_{lambda_1}C(t)f'(t)dt.tag 1
$$
Now we can write if $y=x^2$ and $lambda_n=n^2$ and $C(t)=[sqrt{t}]$ (integer part of $sqrt{t}$):
$$
S=sum_{1leq nleq x}frac{sin(n^2)}{n^a}=sum_{lambda_nleq y}frac{sin(lambda_n)}{lambda_n^{a/2}}=
$$
$$
=[sqrt{y}]frac{sin(y)}{y^{a/2}}-int^{y}_{1}[sqrt{t}]frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt.
$$
But it is $[sqrt{t}]=sqrt{t}-{sqrt{t}}$, where ${sqrt{t}}$ is the fractional part of $sqrt{t}$. Hence
$$
S=-frac{1}{2}Releft[iy^{1/2-a/2}Eleft(frac{1+a}{2},iyright)right]+frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]+sin(1)-{sqrt{y}}frac{sin(y)}{y^{a/2}}+int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt,
$$
where
$$
E(a,z)=int^{infty}_{1}frac{e^{-tz}}{t^a}dt
$$
But when $a>0$ and $yrightarrow+infty$ we have
$$
lim_{yrightarrow+infty}left{-frac{1}{2}Releft[iy^{1/2-a/2}Eleft(frac{1+a}{2},iyright)right]+frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]right}+sin(1)=
$$
$$
=frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]+sin(1)
$$
Also $x$ is positive integer and ${sqrt{y}}=0$.
Hence when $a>0$, then
$$
lim_{xrightarrowinfty}sum^{x}_{n=1}frac{sin(n^2)}{n^a}=frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]+sin(1)+lim_{yrightarrowinfty}int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt
$$
But
$$
int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt=int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{cos(t)t^{a/2}-a/2sin(t)t^{a/2-1}}{t^a}dt=
$$
$$
int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}left(cos(t)t^{-a/2}-a/2sin(t)t^{-a/2-1}right)dt=int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{cos(t)}{t^{a/2}}dt-frac{a}{2}int^{y}_{1}frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2+1}}{sqrt{t}}dt.
$$
Clearly
$$
int^{y}_{1}frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2+1}}{sqrt{t}}dt=2int^{x}_{1}frac{sin(t^2)}{t^{a+1}}{t}dt<infty,
$$
for all $a>0$, since $0leq{t}<1$ and $-1leqsin(t^2)leq 1$, for all $t>0$.
Hence it remains to find under what condition on $a>0$ we have
$$
int^{infty}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{cos(t)}{t^{a/2}}dt=2int^{infty}_{1}cos(t^2)t^{1-a}{t}dt<infty,
$$
knowinig already that for all $0<aleq 1$ we have
$$
int^{infty}_{1}cos(t^2)t^{1-a}dt<infty.
$$
When you applied the partial summation, it seems that you used $C(t)=sqrt t$. However, $C(t)=lfloor sqrt t rfloor$.
– i707107
Jun 18 at 22:00
I saw your edit. Then you have to show that the limit as $yrightarrowinfty$ exists. Otherwise, the proof is incomplete.
– i707107
Nov 13 at 22:46
You cannot just ignore ${t}$ at the last step, since $cos(t^2)$ changes sign infinitely often.
– i707107
15 hours ago
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
I recall a generalization of partial summation formula:
Suppose that $lambda_1,lambda_2,ldots$ is a nondecreasing sequence of real numbers with limit infinity, that $c_1,c_2,ldots$ is an arbitrary sequence of real or complex numbers, and that $f(x)$ has a continuous derivative for $xgeq lambda_1$. Put
$$
C(x)=sum_{lambda_nleq x}c_n,
$$
where the summation is over all $n$ for which $lambda_nleq x$. Then for $xgeqlambda_1$,
$$
sum_{lambda_nleq x}c_nf(lambda_n)=C(x)f(x)-int^{x}_{lambda_1}C(t)f'(t)dt.tag 1
$$
Now we can write if $y=x^2$ and $lambda_n=n^2$ and $C(t)=[sqrt{t}]$ (integer part of $sqrt{t}$):
$$
S=sum_{1leq nleq x}frac{sin(n^2)}{n^a}=sum_{lambda_nleq y}frac{sin(lambda_n)}{lambda_n^{a/2}}=
$$
$$
=[sqrt{y}]frac{sin(y)}{y^{a/2}}-int^{y}_{1}[sqrt{t}]frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt.
$$
But it is $[sqrt{t}]=sqrt{t}-{sqrt{t}}$, where ${sqrt{t}}$ is the fractional part of $sqrt{t}$. Hence
$$
S=-frac{1}{2}Releft[iy^{1/2-a/2}Eleft(frac{1+a}{2},iyright)right]+frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]+sin(1)-{sqrt{y}}frac{sin(y)}{y^{a/2}}+int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt,
$$
where
$$
E(a,z)=int^{infty}_{1}frac{e^{-tz}}{t^a}dt
$$
But when $a>0$ and $yrightarrow+infty$ we have
$$
lim_{yrightarrow+infty}left{-frac{1}{2}Releft[iy^{1/2-a/2}Eleft(frac{1+a}{2},iyright)right]+frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]right}+sin(1)=
$$
$$
=frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]+sin(1)
$$
Also $x$ is positive integer and ${sqrt{y}}=0$.
Hence when $a>0$, then
$$
lim_{xrightarrowinfty}sum^{x}_{n=1}frac{sin(n^2)}{n^a}=frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]+sin(1)+lim_{yrightarrowinfty}int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt
$$
But
$$
int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt=int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{cos(t)t^{a/2}-a/2sin(t)t^{a/2-1}}{t^a}dt=
$$
$$
int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}left(cos(t)t^{-a/2}-a/2sin(t)t^{-a/2-1}right)dt=int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{cos(t)}{t^{a/2}}dt-frac{a}{2}int^{y}_{1}frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2+1}}{sqrt{t}}dt.
$$
Clearly
$$
int^{y}_{1}frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2+1}}{sqrt{t}}dt=2int^{x}_{1}frac{sin(t^2)}{t^{a+1}}{t}dt<infty,
$$
for all $a>0$, since $0leq{t}<1$ and $-1leqsin(t^2)leq 1$, for all $t>0$.
Hence it remains to find under what condition on $a>0$ we have
$$
int^{infty}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{cos(t)}{t^{a/2}}dt=2int^{infty}_{1}cos(t^2)t^{1-a}{t}dt<infty,
$$
knowinig already that for all $0<aleq 1$ we have
$$
int^{infty}_{1}cos(t^2)t^{1-a}dt<infty.
$$
I recall a generalization of partial summation formula:
Suppose that $lambda_1,lambda_2,ldots$ is a nondecreasing sequence of real numbers with limit infinity, that $c_1,c_2,ldots$ is an arbitrary sequence of real or complex numbers, and that $f(x)$ has a continuous derivative for $xgeq lambda_1$. Put
$$
C(x)=sum_{lambda_nleq x}c_n,
$$
where the summation is over all $n$ for which $lambda_nleq x$. Then for $xgeqlambda_1$,
$$
sum_{lambda_nleq x}c_nf(lambda_n)=C(x)f(x)-int^{x}_{lambda_1}C(t)f'(t)dt.tag 1
$$
Now we can write if $y=x^2$ and $lambda_n=n^2$ and $C(t)=[sqrt{t}]$ (integer part of $sqrt{t}$):
$$
S=sum_{1leq nleq x}frac{sin(n^2)}{n^a}=sum_{lambda_nleq y}frac{sin(lambda_n)}{lambda_n^{a/2}}=
$$
$$
=[sqrt{y}]frac{sin(y)}{y^{a/2}}-int^{y}_{1}[sqrt{t}]frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt.
$$
But it is $[sqrt{t}]=sqrt{t}-{sqrt{t}}$, where ${sqrt{t}}$ is the fractional part of $sqrt{t}$. Hence
$$
S=-frac{1}{2}Releft[iy^{1/2-a/2}Eleft(frac{1+a}{2},iyright)right]+frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]+sin(1)-{sqrt{y}}frac{sin(y)}{y^{a/2}}+int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt,
$$
where
$$
E(a,z)=int^{infty}_{1}frac{e^{-tz}}{t^a}dt
$$
But when $a>0$ and $yrightarrow+infty$ we have
$$
lim_{yrightarrow+infty}left{-frac{1}{2}Releft[iy^{1/2-a/2}Eleft(frac{1+a}{2},iyright)right]+frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]right}+sin(1)=
$$
$$
=frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]+sin(1)
$$
Also $x$ is positive integer and ${sqrt{y}}=0$.
Hence when $a>0$, then
$$
lim_{xrightarrowinfty}sum^{x}_{n=1}frac{sin(n^2)}{n^a}=frac{1}{2}Releft[iEleft(frac{1+a}{2},iright)right]+sin(1)+lim_{yrightarrowinfty}int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt
$$
But
$$
int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{d}{dt}left(frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2}}right)dt=int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{cos(t)t^{a/2}-a/2sin(t)t^{a/2-1}}{t^a}dt=
$$
$$
int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}left(cos(t)t^{-a/2}-a/2sin(t)t^{-a/2-1}right)dt=int^{y}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{cos(t)}{t^{a/2}}dt-frac{a}{2}int^{y}_{1}frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2+1}}{sqrt{t}}dt.
$$
Clearly
$$
int^{y}_{1}frac{sin(t)}{t^{a/2+1}}{sqrt{t}}dt=2int^{x}_{1}frac{sin(t^2)}{t^{a+1}}{t}dt<infty,
$$
for all $a>0$, since $0leq{t}<1$ and $-1leqsin(t^2)leq 1$, for all $t>0$.
Hence it remains to find under what condition on $a>0$ we have
$$
int^{infty}_{1}{sqrt{t}}frac{cos(t)}{t^{a/2}}dt=2int^{infty}_{1}cos(t^2)t^{1-a}{t}dt<infty,
$$
knowinig already that for all $0<aleq 1$ we have
$$
int^{infty}_{1}cos(t^2)t^{1-a}dt<infty.
$$
edited yesterday
answered Jun 17 at 7:58
Nikos Bagis
1,967311
1,967311
When you applied the partial summation, it seems that you used $C(t)=sqrt t$. However, $C(t)=lfloor sqrt t rfloor$.
– i707107
Jun 18 at 22:00
I saw your edit. Then you have to show that the limit as $yrightarrowinfty$ exists. Otherwise, the proof is incomplete.
– i707107
Nov 13 at 22:46
You cannot just ignore ${t}$ at the last step, since $cos(t^2)$ changes sign infinitely often.
– i707107
15 hours ago
add a comment |
When you applied the partial summation, it seems that you used $C(t)=sqrt t$. However, $C(t)=lfloor sqrt t rfloor$.
– i707107
Jun 18 at 22:00
I saw your edit. Then you have to show that the limit as $yrightarrowinfty$ exists. Otherwise, the proof is incomplete.
– i707107
Nov 13 at 22:46
You cannot just ignore ${t}$ at the last step, since $cos(t^2)$ changes sign infinitely often.
– i707107
15 hours ago
When you applied the partial summation, it seems that you used $C(t)=sqrt t$. However, $C(t)=lfloor sqrt t rfloor$.
– i707107
Jun 18 at 22:00
When you applied the partial summation, it seems that you used $C(t)=sqrt t$. However, $C(t)=lfloor sqrt t rfloor$.
– i707107
Jun 18 at 22:00
I saw your edit. Then you have to show that the limit as $yrightarrowinfty$ exists. Otherwise, the proof is incomplete.
– i707107
Nov 13 at 22:46
I saw your edit. Then you have to show that the limit as $yrightarrowinfty$ exists. Otherwise, the proof is incomplete.
– i707107
Nov 13 at 22:46
You cannot just ignore ${t}$ at the last step, since $cos(t^2)$ changes sign infinitely often.
– i707107
15 hours ago
You cannot just ignore ${t}$ at the last step, since $cos(t^2)$ changes sign infinitely often.
– i707107
15 hours ago
add a comment |
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f215528%2ftwo-questions-about-weakly-convergent-series-related-to-sinn2-and-weyls-i%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
2
By modelling $sin(n^2)$ as a sequence of independent random variables $X_n$, I would expect a positive answer to the first question, also I would expect the later series to be convergent when $beta > 1/2$ and divergent when $beta < 1/2$. Thus the answer to the second question would be $1/2$.
– blabler
Nov 30 '12 at 4:13
A related question has popped up since this one was asked.
– Douglas B. Staple
Mar 29 '13 at 3:44
1
Applying the argument here, math.stackexchange.com/questions/2270/… we obtain that the first quantity is $leq frac{7}{8}$
– i707107
Jun 8 '13 at 17:33