Does the spell Fog Cloud obscure light sources?
Consider this very basic scenario:
- I grab a rock, and cast the cantrip Light on it, choosing a violet hue as the color for the light.
- I set the rock down on the ground
- I cast Fog Cloud in the area surrounding the lit-up rock
Light reads as casting bright light in a 20' radius, and dim light another 20' away, and Fog Cloud (cast as a first level spell) has a 20' radius. So what happens in this scenario?
Does the
Fog Cloud completely obscure the light source, including the dim light shining 20' outside the Fog Cloud itself?
Light shine outside the Fog Cloud, providing dim light within 20' of the fog cloud?- light from the Light spell diffuse through the Fog Cloud, creating a colored fog cloud?
dnd-5e spells vision-and-light
add a comment |
Consider this very basic scenario:
- I grab a rock, and cast the cantrip Light on it, choosing a violet hue as the color for the light.
- I set the rock down on the ground
- I cast Fog Cloud in the area surrounding the lit-up rock
Light reads as casting bright light in a 20' radius, and dim light another 20' away, and Fog Cloud (cast as a first level spell) has a 20' radius. So what happens in this scenario?
Does the
Fog Cloud completely obscure the light source, including the dim light shining 20' outside the Fog Cloud itself?
Light shine outside the Fog Cloud, providing dim light within 20' of the fog cloud?- light from the Light spell diffuse through the Fog Cloud, creating a colored fog cloud?
dnd-5e spells vision-and-light
add a comment |
Consider this very basic scenario:
- I grab a rock, and cast the cantrip Light on it, choosing a violet hue as the color for the light.
- I set the rock down on the ground
- I cast Fog Cloud in the area surrounding the lit-up rock
Light reads as casting bright light in a 20' radius, and dim light another 20' away, and Fog Cloud (cast as a first level spell) has a 20' radius. So what happens in this scenario?
Does the
Fog Cloud completely obscure the light source, including the dim light shining 20' outside the Fog Cloud itself?
Light shine outside the Fog Cloud, providing dim light within 20' of the fog cloud?- light from the Light spell diffuse through the Fog Cloud, creating a colored fog cloud?
dnd-5e spells vision-and-light
Consider this very basic scenario:
- I grab a rock, and cast the cantrip Light on it, choosing a violet hue as the color for the light.
- I set the rock down on the ground
- I cast Fog Cloud in the area surrounding the lit-up rock
Light reads as casting bright light in a 20' radius, and dim light another 20' away, and Fog Cloud (cast as a first level spell) has a 20' radius. So what happens in this scenario?
Does the
Fog Cloud completely obscure the light source, including the dim light shining 20' outside the Fog Cloud itself?
Light shine outside the Fog Cloud, providing dim light within 20' of the fog cloud?- light from the Light spell diffuse through the Fog Cloud, creating a colored fog cloud?
dnd-5e spells vision-and-light
dnd-5e spells vision-and-light
edited Dec 10 at 20:09
SevenSidedDie♦
204k29656931
204k29656931
asked Dec 10 at 16:17
Xirema
15.4k24493
15.4k24493
add a comment |
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
First off, officially speaking, a spell only does what it says it does. A fog cloud spell creates a sphere of fog, which creates a heavily obscured area. It doesn't explicitly block or douse lights inside the area, as a darkness spell does, so the next thing is to look at what "obscured" does.
A heavily obscured area [...] blocks vision entirely. A creature in a heavily obscured area effectively suffers from the blinded condition
The errata adds:
A heavily obscured area doesn't blind you, but you are effectively blinded when you try to see something obscured by it.
Nothing in there mentions blocking light, only that you can't see through it. This fits well with our everyday understanding of what fog is like; light diffuses through it but is not actually blocked.
For the purpose of the game, then, the light (bright or dim) would extend beyond the fog cloud to the normal distance. The visual effect of this is up to the DM, but yes, in real life, a light in a fog cloud makes the cloud glow from inside, so it's reasonable for the DM to rule that the cloud lights up that way.
3
I'm never a fan of using real life physics to explain magical physics, but I like how you've addressed the difference between blinded and effectively blinded along with the comparison against darkness. I think you've got a great answer without bringing in real world physics.
– NautArch
Dec 10 at 17:34
3
I agree, this is one case where despite not being explicitly based on physics, the rules actually line up pretty well with what would happen in real life.
– Ryan Thompson
Dec 10 at 17:39
add a comment |
According to this tweet by Jeremy Crawford, Fog Cloud blocks vision, not light:
The fog cloud spell blocks vision. It doesn't eliminate light.
So the fog cloud will make it impossible to see your rock, but the rock will cast light inside or outside the fog cloud as normal.
add a comment |
The Light Source is completely obscured
In the Player's Handbook, in Chapter 8: Adventuring, under Environment section, the paragraph on Vision and Light reads as follows, with respect to "Heavy Obscurement":
A heavily obscured area—such as darkness, opaque fog, or dense foliage—blocks vision entirely. A creature in a heavily obscured area effectively suffers from the blinded condition (see the appendix). A heavily obscured area doesn't blind you, but you are effectively blinded when you try to see something obscured by it.
Since the Light source is inside the Fog Cloud, and the Fog Cloud specifically dictates that it generates a "Heavily Obscured" area, it would not be possible to see the Light source—or anything else—inside the Fog Cloud without some kind of ability to see through the Fog Cloud itself.
It's possible that the light source could be completely obscured, while it still makes the fog cloud glow. And this glow could still provide illumination outside the fog cloud. "Completely Obscured" isn't the same as darkness. I don't see any rule that makes a fog cloud change the radius of bright and dim light sources.
– bvstuart
Dec 10 at 17:11
@bvstuart If you can find text to support this interpretation, it would be better to post this as its own answer to this question.
– Xirema
Dec 10 at 17:12
With a strong flashlight directed at your face you can't see a flashlight, but you do see light. On the other hand, spells only do what they say they do, and fog does not say it blocks light, only obscures thingd. Thus, your answer is valid literal answer to the title of the question, but not the spirit of it or three bullets at the end of it.
– Mołot
Dec 11 at 15:05
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["\$", "\$"]]);
});
});
}, "mathjax-editing");
StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "122"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});
function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});
}
});
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f137103%2fdoes-the-spell-fog-cloud-obscure-light-sources%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
First off, officially speaking, a spell only does what it says it does. A fog cloud spell creates a sphere of fog, which creates a heavily obscured area. It doesn't explicitly block or douse lights inside the area, as a darkness spell does, so the next thing is to look at what "obscured" does.
A heavily obscured area [...] blocks vision entirely. A creature in a heavily obscured area effectively suffers from the blinded condition
The errata adds:
A heavily obscured area doesn't blind you, but you are effectively blinded when you try to see something obscured by it.
Nothing in there mentions blocking light, only that you can't see through it. This fits well with our everyday understanding of what fog is like; light diffuses through it but is not actually blocked.
For the purpose of the game, then, the light (bright or dim) would extend beyond the fog cloud to the normal distance. The visual effect of this is up to the DM, but yes, in real life, a light in a fog cloud makes the cloud glow from inside, so it's reasonable for the DM to rule that the cloud lights up that way.
3
I'm never a fan of using real life physics to explain magical physics, but I like how you've addressed the difference between blinded and effectively blinded along with the comparison against darkness. I think you've got a great answer without bringing in real world physics.
– NautArch
Dec 10 at 17:34
3
I agree, this is one case where despite not being explicitly based on physics, the rules actually line up pretty well with what would happen in real life.
– Ryan Thompson
Dec 10 at 17:39
add a comment |
First off, officially speaking, a spell only does what it says it does. A fog cloud spell creates a sphere of fog, which creates a heavily obscured area. It doesn't explicitly block or douse lights inside the area, as a darkness spell does, so the next thing is to look at what "obscured" does.
A heavily obscured area [...] blocks vision entirely. A creature in a heavily obscured area effectively suffers from the blinded condition
The errata adds:
A heavily obscured area doesn't blind you, but you are effectively blinded when you try to see something obscured by it.
Nothing in there mentions blocking light, only that you can't see through it. This fits well with our everyday understanding of what fog is like; light diffuses through it but is not actually blocked.
For the purpose of the game, then, the light (bright or dim) would extend beyond the fog cloud to the normal distance. The visual effect of this is up to the DM, but yes, in real life, a light in a fog cloud makes the cloud glow from inside, so it's reasonable for the DM to rule that the cloud lights up that way.
3
I'm never a fan of using real life physics to explain magical physics, but I like how you've addressed the difference between blinded and effectively blinded along with the comparison against darkness. I think you've got a great answer without bringing in real world physics.
– NautArch
Dec 10 at 17:34
3
I agree, this is one case where despite not being explicitly based on physics, the rules actually line up pretty well with what would happen in real life.
– Ryan Thompson
Dec 10 at 17:39
add a comment |
First off, officially speaking, a spell only does what it says it does. A fog cloud spell creates a sphere of fog, which creates a heavily obscured area. It doesn't explicitly block or douse lights inside the area, as a darkness spell does, so the next thing is to look at what "obscured" does.
A heavily obscured area [...] blocks vision entirely. A creature in a heavily obscured area effectively suffers from the blinded condition
The errata adds:
A heavily obscured area doesn't blind you, but you are effectively blinded when you try to see something obscured by it.
Nothing in there mentions blocking light, only that you can't see through it. This fits well with our everyday understanding of what fog is like; light diffuses through it but is not actually blocked.
For the purpose of the game, then, the light (bright or dim) would extend beyond the fog cloud to the normal distance. The visual effect of this is up to the DM, but yes, in real life, a light in a fog cloud makes the cloud glow from inside, so it's reasonable for the DM to rule that the cloud lights up that way.
First off, officially speaking, a spell only does what it says it does. A fog cloud spell creates a sphere of fog, which creates a heavily obscured area. It doesn't explicitly block or douse lights inside the area, as a darkness spell does, so the next thing is to look at what "obscured" does.
A heavily obscured area [...] blocks vision entirely. A creature in a heavily obscured area effectively suffers from the blinded condition
The errata adds:
A heavily obscured area doesn't blind you, but you are effectively blinded when you try to see something obscured by it.
Nothing in there mentions blocking light, only that you can't see through it. This fits well with our everyday understanding of what fog is like; light diffuses through it but is not actually blocked.
For the purpose of the game, then, the light (bright or dim) would extend beyond the fog cloud to the normal distance. The visual effect of this is up to the DM, but yes, in real life, a light in a fog cloud makes the cloud glow from inside, so it's reasonable for the DM to rule that the cloud lights up that way.
answered Dec 10 at 17:27
Darth Pseudonym
11.1k12862
11.1k12862
3
I'm never a fan of using real life physics to explain magical physics, but I like how you've addressed the difference between blinded and effectively blinded along with the comparison against darkness. I think you've got a great answer without bringing in real world physics.
– NautArch
Dec 10 at 17:34
3
I agree, this is one case where despite not being explicitly based on physics, the rules actually line up pretty well with what would happen in real life.
– Ryan Thompson
Dec 10 at 17:39
add a comment |
3
I'm never a fan of using real life physics to explain magical physics, but I like how you've addressed the difference between blinded and effectively blinded along with the comparison against darkness. I think you've got a great answer without bringing in real world physics.
– NautArch
Dec 10 at 17:34
3
I agree, this is one case where despite not being explicitly based on physics, the rules actually line up pretty well with what would happen in real life.
– Ryan Thompson
Dec 10 at 17:39
3
3
I'm never a fan of using real life physics to explain magical physics, but I like how you've addressed the difference between blinded and effectively blinded along with the comparison against darkness. I think you've got a great answer without bringing in real world physics.
– NautArch
Dec 10 at 17:34
I'm never a fan of using real life physics to explain magical physics, but I like how you've addressed the difference between blinded and effectively blinded along with the comparison against darkness. I think you've got a great answer without bringing in real world physics.
– NautArch
Dec 10 at 17:34
3
3
I agree, this is one case where despite not being explicitly based on physics, the rules actually line up pretty well with what would happen in real life.
– Ryan Thompson
Dec 10 at 17:39
I agree, this is one case where despite not being explicitly based on physics, the rules actually line up pretty well with what would happen in real life.
– Ryan Thompson
Dec 10 at 17:39
add a comment |
According to this tweet by Jeremy Crawford, Fog Cloud blocks vision, not light:
The fog cloud spell blocks vision. It doesn't eliminate light.
So the fog cloud will make it impossible to see your rock, but the rock will cast light inside or outside the fog cloud as normal.
add a comment |
According to this tweet by Jeremy Crawford, Fog Cloud blocks vision, not light:
The fog cloud spell blocks vision. It doesn't eliminate light.
So the fog cloud will make it impossible to see your rock, but the rock will cast light inside or outside the fog cloud as normal.
add a comment |
According to this tweet by Jeremy Crawford, Fog Cloud blocks vision, not light:
The fog cloud spell blocks vision. It doesn't eliminate light.
So the fog cloud will make it impossible to see your rock, but the rock will cast light inside or outside the fog cloud as normal.
According to this tweet by Jeremy Crawford, Fog Cloud blocks vision, not light:
The fog cloud spell blocks vision. It doesn't eliminate light.
So the fog cloud will make it impossible to see your rock, but the rock will cast light inside or outside the fog cloud as normal.
edited Dec 10 at 17:36
NautArch
52.8k8186356
52.8k8186356
answered Dec 10 at 17:21
bvstuart
1,053310
1,053310
add a comment |
add a comment |
The Light Source is completely obscured
In the Player's Handbook, in Chapter 8: Adventuring, under Environment section, the paragraph on Vision and Light reads as follows, with respect to "Heavy Obscurement":
A heavily obscured area—such as darkness, opaque fog, or dense foliage—blocks vision entirely. A creature in a heavily obscured area effectively suffers from the blinded condition (see the appendix). A heavily obscured area doesn't blind you, but you are effectively blinded when you try to see something obscured by it.
Since the Light source is inside the Fog Cloud, and the Fog Cloud specifically dictates that it generates a "Heavily Obscured" area, it would not be possible to see the Light source—or anything else—inside the Fog Cloud without some kind of ability to see through the Fog Cloud itself.
It's possible that the light source could be completely obscured, while it still makes the fog cloud glow. And this glow could still provide illumination outside the fog cloud. "Completely Obscured" isn't the same as darkness. I don't see any rule that makes a fog cloud change the radius of bright and dim light sources.
– bvstuart
Dec 10 at 17:11
@bvstuart If you can find text to support this interpretation, it would be better to post this as its own answer to this question.
– Xirema
Dec 10 at 17:12
With a strong flashlight directed at your face you can't see a flashlight, but you do see light. On the other hand, spells only do what they say they do, and fog does not say it blocks light, only obscures thingd. Thus, your answer is valid literal answer to the title of the question, but not the spirit of it or three bullets at the end of it.
– Mołot
Dec 11 at 15:05
add a comment |
The Light Source is completely obscured
In the Player's Handbook, in Chapter 8: Adventuring, under Environment section, the paragraph on Vision and Light reads as follows, with respect to "Heavy Obscurement":
A heavily obscured area—such as darkness, opaque fog, or dense foliage—blocks vision entirely. A creature in a heavily obscured area effectively suffers from the blinded condition (see the appendix). A heavily obscured area doesn't blind you, but you are effectively blinded when you try to see something obscured by it.
Since the Light source is inside the Fog Cloud, and the Fog Cloud specifically dictates that it generates a "Heavily Obscured" area, it would not be possible to see the Light source—or anything else—inside the Fog Cloud without some kind of ability to see through the Fog Cloud itself.
It's possible that the light source could be completely obscured, while it still makes the fog cloud glow. And this glow could still provide illumination outside the fog cloud. "Completely Obscured" isn't the same as darkness. I don't see any rule that makes a fog cloud change the radius of bright and dim light sources.
– bvstuart
Dec 10 at 17:11
@bvstuart If you can find text to support this interpretation, it would be better to post this as its own answer to this question.
– Xirema
Dec 10 at 17:12
With a strong flashlight directed at your face you can't see a flashlight, but you do see light. On the other hand, spells only do what they say they do, and fog does not say it blocks light, only obscures thingd. Thus, your answer is valid literal answer to the title of the question, but not the spirit of it or three bullets at the end of it.
– Mołot
Dec 11 at 15:05
add a comment |
The Light Source is completely obscured
In the Player's Handbook, in Chapter 8: Adventuring, under Environment section, the paragraph on Vision and Light reads as follows, with respect to "Heavy Obscurement":
A heavily obscured area—such as darkness, opaque fog, or dense foliage—blocks vision entirely. A creature in a heavily obscured area effectively suffers from the blinded condition (see the appendix). A heavily obscured area doesn't blind you, but you are effectively blinded when you try to see something obscured by it.
Since the Light source is inside the Fog Cloud, and the Fog Cloud specifically dictates that it generates a "Heavily Obscured" area, it would not be possible to see the Light source—or anything else—inside the Fog Cloud without some kind of ability to see through the Fog Cloud itself.
The Light Source is completely obscured
In the Player's Handbook, in Chapter 8: Adventuring, under Environment section, the paragraph on Vision and Light reads as follows, with respect to "Heavy Obscurement":
A heavily obscured area—such as darkness, opaque fog, or dense foliage—blocks vision entirely. A creature in a heavily obscured area effectively suffers from the blinded condition (see the appendix). A heavily obscured area doesn't blind you, but you are effectively blinded when you try to see something obscured by it.
Since the Light source is inside the Fog Cloud, and the Fog Cloud specifically dictates that it generates a "Heavily Obscured" area, it would not be possible to see the Light source—or anything else—inside the Fog Cloud without some kind of ability to see through the Fog Cloud itself.
edited Dec 10 at 17:48
answered Dec 10 at 16:17
Xirema
15.4k24493
15.4k24493
It's possible that the light source could be completely obscured, while it still makes the fog cloud glow. And this glow could still provide illumination outside the fog cloud. "Completely Obscured" isn't the same as darkness. I don't see any rule that makes a fog cloud change the radius of bright and dim light sources.
– bvstuart
Dec 10 at 17:11
@bvstuart If you can find text to support this interpretation, it would be better to post this as its own answer to this question.
– Xirema
Dec 10 at 17:12
With a strong flashlight directed at your face you can't see a flashlight, but you do see light. On the other hand, spells only do what they say they do, and fog does not say it blocks light, only obscures thingd. Thus, your answer is valid literal answer to the title of the question, but not the spirit of it or three bullets at the end of it.
– Mołot
Dec 11 at 15:05
add a comment |
It's possible that the light source could be completely obscured, while it still makes the fog cloud glow. And this glow could still provide illumination outside the fog cloud. "Completely Obscured" isn't the same as darkness. I don't see any rule that makes a fog cloud change the radius of bright and dim light sources.
– bvstuart
Dec 10 at 17:11
@bvstuart If you can find text to support this interpretation, it would be better to post this as its own answer to this question.
– Xirema
Dec 10 at 17:12
With a strong flashlight directed at your face you can't see a flashlight, but you do see light. On the other hand, spells only do what they say they do, and fog does not say it blocks light, only obscures thingd. Thus, your answer is valid literal answer to the title of the question, but not the spirit of it or three bullets at the end of it.
– Mołot
Dec 11 at 15:05
It's possible that the light source could be completely obscured, while it still makes the fog cloud glow. And this glow could still provide illumination outside the fog cloud. "Completely Obscured" isn't the same as darkness. I don't see any rule that makes a fog cloud change the radius of bright and dim light sources.
– bvstuart
Dec 10 at 17:11
It's possible that the light source could be completely obscured, while it still makes the fog cloud glow. And this glow could still provide illumination outside the fog cloud. "Completely Obscured" isn't the same as darkness. I don't see any rule that makes a fog cloud change the radius of bright and dim light sources.
– bvstuart
Dec 10 at 17:11
@bvstuart If you can find text to support this interpretation, it would be better to post this as its own answer to this question.
– Xirema
Dec 10 at 17:12
@bvstuart If you can find text to support this interpretation, it would be better to post this as its own answer to this question.
– Xirema
Dec 10 at 17:12
With a strong flashlight directed at your face you can't see a flashlight, but you do see light. On the other hand, spells only do what they say they do, and fog does not say it blocks light, only obscures thingd. Thus, your answer is valid literal answer to the title of the question, but not the spirit of it or three bullets at the end of it.
– Mołot
Dec 11 at 15:05
With a strong flashlight directed at your face you can't see a flashlight, but you do see light. On the other hand, spells only do what they say they do, and fog does not say it blocks light, only obscures thingd. Thus, your answer is valid literal answer to the title of the question, but not the spirit of it or three bullets at the end of it.
– Mołot
Dec 11 at 15:05
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Role-playing Games Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.
Please pay close attention to the following guidance:
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f137103%2fdoes-the-spell-fog-cloud-obscure-light-sources%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown