Are Optane PCIe 3.0 + 2282 cards compatible with older motherboards?
A lot gets written about Optane compatibility, and how it needs a current generation motherboard. But I can't find any reference to whether that's only for Optane directly plugged into RAM slots or used for booting.
When I research it, even Intel's FAQ on Optane just assumes it'll be used as a motherboard NVDIMM, RST chipset cache device or bootable device. It doesn't say a word about data drive usage, and says nothing either way about other formats of XPoint 3D/Optane.
So what I'm trying to find out is a definitive answer whether Optane 2282 cards, and Optane full-size PCIe 3.0 NVMe cards, are compatible with older generations of motherboard.
Also, if 2282 cards are compatible, can they be plugged directly into older motherboards with onboard 2282 slits, or mounted on PCIe with any normal + cheap 2282->PCIe adapter card?
I'd expect them to be as I expect them to have all needed controller/interfacing for both of these buses onboard (other than booting which I don't care about). I'd actually be surprised if they weren't compatible. But I don't want to spend money on one, unless I'm sure.
compatibility nvme optane
add a comment |
A lot gets written about Optane compatibility, and how it needs a current generation motherboard. But I can't find any reference to whether that's only for Optane directly plugged into RAM slots or used for booting.
When I research it, even Intel's FAQ on Optane just assumes it'll be used as a motherboard NVDIMM, RST chipset cache device or bootable device. It doesn't say a word about data drive usage, and says nothing either way about other formats of XPoint 3D/Optane.
So what I'm trying to find out is a definitive answer whether Optane 2282 cards, and Optane full-size PCIe 3.0 NVMe cards, are compatible with older generations of motherboard.
Also, if 2282 cards are compatible, can they be plugged directly into older motherboards with onboard 2282 slits, or mounted on PCIe with any normal + cheap 2282->PCIe adapter card?
I'd expect them to be as I expect them to have all needed controller/interfacing for both of these buses onboard (other than booting which I don't care about). I'd actually be surprised if they weren't compatible. But I don't want to spend money on one, unless I'm sure.
compatibility nvme optane
add a comment |
A lot gets written about Optane compatibility, and how it needs a current generation motherboard. But I can't find any reference to whether that's only for Optane directly plugged into RAM slots or used for booting.
When I research it, even Intel's FAQ on Optane just assumes it'll be used as a motherboard NVDIMM, RST chipset cache device or bootable device. It doesn't say a word about data drive usage, and says nothing either way about other formats of XPoint 3D/Optane.
So what I'm trying to find out is a definitive answer whether Optane 2282 cards, and Optane full-size PCIe 3.0 NVMe cards, are compatible with older generations of motherboard.
Also, if 2282 cards are compatible, can they be plugged directly into older motherboards with onboard 2282 slits, or mounted on PCIe with any normal + cheap 2282->PCIe adapter card?
I'd expect them to be as I expect them to have all needed controller/interfacing for both of these buses onboard (other than booting which I don't care about). I'd actually be surprised if they weren't compatible. But I don't want to spend money on one, unless I'm sure.
compatibility nvme optane
A lot gets written about Optane compatibility, and how it needs a current generation motherboard. But I can't find any reference to whether that's only for Optane directly plugged into RAM slots or used for booting.
When I research it, even Intel's FAQ on Optane just assumes it'll be used as a motherboard NVDIMM, RST chipset cache device or bootable device. It doesn't say a word about data drive usage, and says nothing either way about other formats of XPoint 3D/Optane.
So what I'm trying to find out is a definitive answer whether Optane 2282 cards, and Optane full-size PCIe 3.0 NVMe cards, are compatible with older generations of motherboard.
Also, if 2282 cards are compatible, can they be plugged directly into older motherboards with onboard 2282 slits, or mounted on PCIe with any normal + cheap 2282->PCIe adapter card?
I'd expect them to be as I expect them to have all needed controller/interfacing for both of these buses onboard (other than booting which I don't care about). I'd actually be surprised if they weren't compatible. But I don't want to spend money on one, unless I'm sure.
compatibility nvme optane
compatibility nvme optane
asked Feb 12 at 19:49
StilezStilez
78011022
78011022
add a comment |
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
I think you have the same misunderstanding as in the post
Can Intel Optane memory compensate for less RAM?.
Read in that post why Optane "memory" is not RAM.
See also the video in
How to Install and Manage Intel® Optane™ Memory in Windows® 10 (Basic)
to understand that an M.2 connector is required on the motherboard for Optane
and how to connect the Optane card to the motherboard.
Finally, you will find your answer in the Intel post of
Where to Buy Intel® Optane™ Memory Ready Motherboards.
But please note all the other requirements that are listed in
Intel® Optane™ Memory: Before You Buy, Key Requirements.
(Personally, I don't see why anyone will buy Optane instead of investing in a
real SSD, but that's only my opinion.)
They do make Optane DDR4 NVDIMMs which apparently just act as persistent RAM (meant for servers I suppose).
– grawity
Feb 12 at 20:50
None of this is relevant. A PCIe NVMe for very high speed data drive use will never be confused with RAM; M.2 is never "required" to plug in a PCIe NVMe; "where to buy" is a motherboard list,it doesn't explicitly answer whether or not Optane PCIe cards that are electrically compatible with old moboards can be used on them (it's just listing those natively usable for onboard caching/acceleration via the 370). As for the last comment, give it a break: I'm already using the fastest pre-Optane NVMe datacentre SSD on the planet (Intel P3700), tracing shows its I/O latency is the bottleneck.
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 20:57
@grawity: Optane RAM is slower than normal DDRn and only works on Xeon systems, not to mention that it isn't out yet and is likely to be prohibitively expensive for a home PC.
– harrymc
Feb 12 at 20:58
(Sorry grawity - that was a reply to @harrymc, not to you)
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 21:00
1
Harry - contrary to what you "don't see", I own not one, but >2< pre-Optane motherboards with native M.2 PCIe 3.0 x4/x2/x1 NVMe slots (gigabyte.com/Motherboard/GA-Z170-HD3P-rev-10#sp explicitly confirms, as does my asrock.com/mb/Intel/Z97%20Extreme6, many others exist too). You're not making a good case that you have done any fact-checking at all. All I see is inaccurate but widely held assumptions, including the laughable and dismissive throwaway that I "just" need to upgrade my Intel P3700 NVMe to a "real" SSD (!). If it was that clear I'd know the answer already.
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 21:36
|
show 11 more comments
It's now clear that Optane SSDs are 100% compatible with older chipsets and CPUs - guesses about CPU instruction sets are mistaken.
Over a year ago, ServeTheHome.com tested running their entire website on Optane 900p SSDs, to see what difference it made. They reported that
We put copies of the entire STH main site on a dual Intel Xeon E5-2698 V4 system that is identical to another system we have set up in the hosting cluster save that this node had 2x Intel Optane 900p 280GB AICs, 2x Intel DC P3600 1.6TB NVMe AICs, and 2x Intel DC P3700 400GB 2.5″ SSDs.....
We [did] a second day entirely on the Intel Optane 900p 280GB SSDs [and tweeted] "The STH main site is being served via ZFS mirrored Intel Optane 900p NVMe SSDs for a few hours today just to generate some test data.."
— STH (@ServeTheHome) January 2, 2018
What's interesting in this post is a throwaway comment - the "v4" bit. The Xeon E5-2698 v4 is a Broadwell EP CPU (LGA 2011v3). From that alone, it's clear immediately that S.T.H. found Optane SSDs to be compatible enough, and stable enough, with Broadwell era CPUs, to serve their entire site during testing, and to gain very positive impressions on the combination as well.
People have even reported getting Optane to work on old Ivy Bridge 4790k motherboards running Windows 7 - suboptimally for sure, but clearly no fundamental hardware incompatibility.
tl;dr answer:
The limits on using Optane SSD like you'd use any other SSD, are apparently just the need for NVMe support (in the chipset+BIOS/UEFI+driver) and the lack of appropriate physical connectors, both of which are more likely to be missing as boards get older.
Very old versions of NVMe in the BIOS/UEFI might also need to be updated - there are hints about this in a couple of forum posts but no confirmation one way or the other so far.
- (Relevant and not-well-known resource: bios-mods.com is a website that specialises in updating bios firmware modules for NICs, SATA, RST, USB, etc to newer versions, so the boards can be used with newer hardware, drivers or OSes, it could be helpful if stuck)
The main reported issue in older chipsets/CPUs seems to be related to NVMe driver support (in Windows at least), which wasn't yet included in Intel RST at that time.
The requirement for a "latest CPU+chipset" only seems to apply if you want to use Intel's Optane-specific caching/acceleration/NVDIMM functionality, because that needs chipset support. But ordinary SSD use - apparently no issues.
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "3"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});
function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: true,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: 10,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});
}
});
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fsuperuser.com%2fquestions%2f1404980%2fare-optane-pcie-3-0-2282-cards-compatible-with-older-motherboards%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
I think you have the same misunderstanding as in the post
Can Intel Optane memory compensate for less RAM?.
Read in that post why Optane "memory" is not RAM.
See also the video in
How to Install and Manage Intel® Optane™ Memory in Windows® 10 (Basic)
to understand that an M.2 connector is required on the motherboard for Optane
and how to connect the Optane card to the motherboard.
Finally, you will find your answer in the Intel post of
Where to Buy Intel® Optane™ Memory Ready Motherboards.
But please note all the other requirements that are listed in
Intel® Optane™ Memory: Before You Buy, Key Requirements.
(Personally, I don't see why anyone will buy Optane instead of investing in a
real SSD, but that's only my opinion.)
They do make Optane DDR4 NVDIMMs which apparently just act as persistent RAM (meant for servers I suppose).
– grawity
Feb 12 at 20:50
None of this is relevant. A PCIe NVMe for very high speed data drive use will never be confused with RAM; M.2 is never "required" to plug in a PCIe NVMe; "where to buy" is a motherboard list,it doesn't explicitly answer whether or not Optane PCIe cards that are electrically compatible with old moboards can be used on them (it's just listing those natively usable for onboard caching/acceleration via the 370). As for the last comment, give it a break: I'm already using the fastest pre-Optane NVMe datacentre SSD on the planet (Intel P3700), tracing shows its I/O latency is the bottleneck.
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 20:57
@grawity: Optane RAM is slower than normal DDRn and only works on Xeon systems, not to mention that it isn't out yet and is likely to be prohibitively expensive for a home PC.
– harrymc
Feb 12 at 20:58
(Sorry grawity - that was a reply to @harrymc, not to you)
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 21:00
1
Harry - contrary to what you "don't see", I own not one, but >2< pre-Optane motherboards with native M.2 PCIe 3.0 x4/x2/x1 NVMe slots (gigabyte.com/Motherboard/GA-Z170-HD3P-rev-10#sp explicitly confirms, as does my asrock.com/mb/Intel/Z97%20Extreme6, many others exist too). You're not making a good case that you have done any fact-checking at all. All I see is inaccurate but widely held assumptions, including the laughable and dismissive throwaway that I "just" need to upgrade my Intel P3700 NVMe to a "real" SSD (!). If it was that clear I'd know the answer already.
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 21:36
|
show 11 more comments
I think you have the same misunderstanding as in the post
Can Intel Optane memory compensate for less RAM?.
Read in that post why Optane "memory" is not RAM.
See also the video in
How to Install and Manage Intel® Optane™ Memory in Windows® 10 (Basic)
to understand that an M.2 connector is required on the motherboard for Optane
and how to connect the Optane card to the motherboard.
Finally, you will find your answer in the Intel post of
Where to Buy Intel® Optane™ Memory Ready Motherboards.
But please note all the other requirements that are listed in
Intel® Optane™ Memory: Before You Buy, Key Requirements.
(Personally, I don't see why anyone will buy Optane instead of investing in a
real SSD, but that's only my opinion.)
They do make Optane DDR4 NVDIMMs which apparently just act as persistent RAM (meant for servers I suppose).
– grawity
Feb 12 at 20:50
None of this is relevant. A PCIe NVMe for very high speed data drive use will never be confused with RAM; M.2 is never "required" to plug in a PCIe NVMe; "where to buy" is a motherboard list,it doesn't explicitly answer whether or not Optane PCIe cards that are electrically compatible with old moboards can be used on them (it's just listing those natively usable for onboard caching/acceleration via the 370). As for the last comment, give it a break: I'm already using the fastest pre-Optane NVMe datacentre SSD on the planet (Intel P3700), tracing shows its I/O latency is the bottleneck.
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 20:57
@grawity: Optane RAM is slower than normal DDRn and only works on Xeon systems, not to mention that it isn't out yet and is likely to be prohibitively expensive for a home PC.
– harrymc
Feb 12 at 20:58
(Sorry grawity - that was a reply to @harrymc, not to you)
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 21:00
1
Harry - contrary to what you "don't see", I own not one, but >2< pre-Optane motherboards with native M.2 PCIe 3.0 x4/x2/x1 NVMe slots (gigabyte.com/Motherboard/GA-Z170-HD3P-rev-10#sp explicitly confirms, as does my asrock.com/mb/Intel/Z97%20Extreme6, many others exist too). You're not making a good case that you have done any fact-checking at all. All I see is inaccurate but widely held assumptions, including the laughable and dismissive throwaway that I "just" need to upgrade my Intel P3700 NVMe to a "real" SSD (!). If it was that clear I'd know the answer already.
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 21:36
|
show 11 more comments
I think you have the same misunderstanding as in the post
Can Intel Optane memory compensate for less RAM?.
Read in that post why Optane "memory" is not RAM.
See also the video in
How to Install and Manage Intel® Optane™ Memory in Windows® 10 (Basic)
to understand that an M.2 connector is required on the motherboard for Optane
and how to connect the Optane card to the motherboard.
Finally, you will find your answer in the Intel post of
Where to Buy Intel® Optane™ Memory Ready Motherboards.
But please note all the other requirements that are listed in
Intel® Optane™ Memory: Before You Buy, Key Requirements.
(Personally, I don't see why anyone will buy Optane instead of investing in a
real SSD, but that's only my opinion.)
I think you have the same misunderstanding as in the post
Can Intel Optane memory compensate for less RAM?.
Read in that post why Optane "memory" is not RAM.
See also the video in
How to Install and Manage Intel® Optane™ Memory in Windows® 10 (Basic)
to understand that an M.2 connector is required on the motherboard for Optane
and how to connect the Optane card to the motherboard.
Finally, you will find your answer in the Intel post of
Where to Buy Intel® Optane™ Memory Ready Motherboards.
But please note all the other requirements that are listed in
Intel® Optane™ Memory: Before You Buy, Key Requirements.
(Personally, I don't see why anyone will buy Optane instead of investing in a
real SSD, but that's only my opinion.)
answered Feb 12 at 20:32
harrymcharrymc
261k14271578
261k14271578
They do make Optane DDR4 NVDIMMs which apparently just act as persistent RAM (meant for servers I suppose).
– grawity
Feb 12 at 20:50
None of this is relevant. A PCIe NVMe for very high speed data drive use will never be confused with RAM; M.2 is never "required" to plug in a PCIe NVMe; "where to buy" is a motherboard list,it doesn't explicitly answer whether or not Optane PCIe cards that are electrically compatible with old moboards can be used on them (it's just listing those natively usable for onboard caching/acceleration via the 370). As for the last comment, give it a break: I'm already using the fastest pre-Optane NVMe datacentre SSD on the planet (Intel P3700), tracing shows its I/O latency is the bottleneck.
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 20:57
@grawity: Optane RAM is slower than normal DDRn and only works on Xeon systems, not to mention that it isn't out yet and is likely to be prohibitively expensive for a home PC.
– harrymc
Feb 12 at 20:58
(Sorry grawity - that was a reply to @harrymc, not to you)
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 21:00
1
Harry - contrary to what you "don't see", I own not one, but >2< pre-Optane motherboards with native M.2 PCIe 3.0 x4/x2/x1 NVMe slots (gigabyte.com/Motherboard/GA-Z170-HD3P-rev-10#sp explicitly confirms, as does my asrock.com/mb/Intel/Z97%20Extreme6, many others exist too). You're not making a good case that you have done any fact-checking at all. All I see is inaccurate but widely held assumptions, including the laughable and dismissive throwaway that I "just" need to upgrade my Intel P3700 NVMe to a "real" SSD (!). If it was that clear I'd know the answer already.
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 21:36
|
show 11 more comments
They do make Optane DDR4 NVDIMMs which apparently just act as persistent RAM (meant for servers I suppose).
– grawity
Feb 12 at 20:50
None of this is relevant. A PCIe NVMe for very high speed data drive use will never be confused with RAM; M.2 is never "required" to plug in a PCIe NVMe; "where to buy" is a motherboard list,it doesn't explicitly answer whether or not Optane PCIe cards that are electrically compatible with old moboards can be used on them (it's just listing those natively usable for onboard caching/acceleration via the 370). As for the last comment, give it a break: I'm already using the fastest pre-Optane NVMe datacentre SSD on the planet (Intel P3700), tracing shows its I/O latency is the bottleneck.
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 20:57
@grawity: Optane RAM is slower than normal DDRn and only works on Xeon systems, not to mention that it isn't out yet and is likely to be prohibitively expensive for a home PC.
– harrymc
Feb 12 at 20:58
(Sorry grawity - that was a reply to @harrymc, not to you)
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 21:00
1
Harry - contrary to what you "don't see", I own not one, but >2< pre-Optane motherboards with native M.2 PCIe 3.0 x4/x2/x1 NVMe slots (gigabyte.com/Motherboard/GA-Z170-HD3P-rev-10#sp explicitly confirms, as does my asrock.com/mb/Intel/Z97%20Extreme6, many others exist too). You're not making a good case that you have done any fact-checking at all. All I see is inaccurate but widely held assumptions, including the laughable and dismissive throwaway that I "just" need to upgrade my Intel P3700 NVMe to a "real" SSD (!). If it was that clear I'd know the answer already.
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 21:36
They do make Optane DDR4 NVDIMMs which apparently just act as persistent RAM (meant for servers I suppose).
– grawity
Feb 12 at 20:50
They do make Optane DDR4 NVDIMMs which apparently just act as persistent RAM (meant for servers I suppose).
– grawity
Feb 12 at 20:50
None of this is relevant. A PCIe NVMe for very high speed data drive use will never be confused with RAM; M.2 is never "required" to plug in a PCIe NVMe; "where to buy" is a motherboard list,it doesn't explicitly answer whether or not Optane PCIe cards that are electrically compatible with old moboards can be used on them (it's just listing those natively usable for onboard caching/acceleration via the 370). As for the last comment, give it a break: I'm already using the fastest pre-Optane NVMe datacentre SSD on the planet (Intel P3700), tracing shows its I/O latency is the bottleneck.
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 20:57
None of this is relevant. A PCIe NVMe for very high speed data drive use will never be confused with RAM; M.2 is never "required" to plug in a PCIe NVMe; "where to buy" is a motherboard list,it doesn't explicitly answer whether or not Optane PCIe cards that are electrically compatible with old moboards can be used on them (it's just listing those natively usable for onboard caching/acceleration via the 370). As for the last comment, give it a break: I'm already using the fastest pre-Optane NVMe datacentre SSD on the planet (Intel P3700), tracing shows its I/O latency is the bottleneck.
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 20:57
@grawity: Optane RAM is slower than normal DDRn and only works on Xeon systems, not to mention that it isn't out yet and is likely to be prohibitively expensive for a home PC.
– harrymc
Feb 12 at 20:58
@grawity: Optane RAM is slower than normal DDRn and only works on Xeon systems, not to mention that it isn't out yet and is likely to be prohibitively expensive for a home PC.
– harrymc
Feb 12 at 20:58
(Sorry grawity - that was a reply to @harrymc, not to you)
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 21:00
(Sorry grawity - that was a reply to @harrymc, not to you)
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 21:00
1
1
Harry - contrary to what you "don't see", I own not one, but >2< pre-Optane motherboards with native M.2 PCIe 3.0 x4/x2/x1 NVMe slots (gigabyte.com/Motherboard/GA-Z170-HD3P-rev-10#sp explicitly confirms, as does my asrock.com/mb/Intel/Z97%20Extreme6, many others exist too). You're not making a good case that you have done any fact-checking at all. All I see is inaccurate but widely held assumptions, including the laughable and dismissive throwaway that I "just" need to upgrade my Intel P3700 NVMe to a "real" SSD (!). If it was that clear I'd know the answer already.
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 21:36
Harry - contrary to what you "don't see", I own not one, but >2< pre-Optane motherboards with native M.2 PCIe 3.0 x4/x2/x1 NVMe slots (gigabyte.com/Motherboard/GA-Z170-HD3P-rev-10#sp explicitly confirms, as does my asrock.com/mb/Intel/Z97%20Extreme6, many others exist too). You're not making a good case that you have done any fact-checking at all. All I see is inaccurate but widely held assumptions, including the laughable and dismissive throwaway that I "just" need to upgrade my Intel P3700 NVMe to a "real" SSD (!). If it was that clear I'd know the answer already.
– Stilez
Feb 12 at 21:36
|
show 11 more comments
It's now clear that Optane SSDs are 100% compatible with older chipsets and CPUs - guesses about CPU instruction sets are mistaken.
Over a year ago, ServeTheHome.com tested running their entire website on Optane 900p SSDs, to see what difference it made. They reported that
We put copies of the entire STH main site on a dual Intel Xeon E5-2698 V4 system that is identical to another system we have set up in the hosting cluster save that this node had 2x Intel Optane 900p 280GB AICs, 2x Intel DC P3600 1.6TB NVMe AICs, and 2x Intel DC P3700 400GB 2.5″ SSDs.....
We [did] a second day entirely on the Intel Optane 900p 280GB SSDs [and tweeted] "The STH main site is being served via ZFS mirrored Intel Optane 900p NVMe SSDs for a few hours today just to generate some test data.."
— STH (@ServeTheHome) January 2, 2018
What's interesting in this post is a throwaway comment - the "v4" bit. The Xeon E5-2698 v4 is a Broadwell EP CPU (LGA 2011v3). From that alone, it's clear immediately that S.T.H. found Optane SSDs to be compatible enough, and stable enough, with Broadwell era CPUs, to serve their entire site during testing, and to gain very positive impressions on the combination as well.
People have even reported getting Optane to work on old Ivy Bridge 4790k motherboards running Windows 7 - suboptimally for sure, but clearly no fundamental hardware incompatibility.
tl;dr answer:
The limits on using Optane SSD like you'd use any other SSD, are apparently just the need for NVMe support (in the chipset+BIOS/UEFI+driver) and the lack of appropriate physical connectors, both of which are more likely to be missing as boards get older.
Very old versions of NVMe in the BIOS/UEFI might also need to be updated - there are hints about this in a couple of forum posts but no confirmation one way or the other so far.
- (Relevant and not-well-known resource: bios-mods.com is a website that specialises in updating bios firmware modules for NICs, SATA, RST, USB, etc to newer versions, so the boards can be used with newer hardware, drivers or OSes, it could be helpful if stuck)
The main reported issue in older chipsets/CPUs seems to be related to NVMe driver support (in Windows at least), which wasn't yet included in Intel RST at that time.
The requirement for a "latest CPU+chipset" only seems to apply if you want to use Intel's Optane-specific caching/acceleration/NVDIMM functionality, because that needs chipset support. But ordinary SSD use - apparently no issues.
add a comment |
It's now clear that Optane SSDs are 100% compatible with older chipsets and CPUs - guesses about CPU instruction sets are mistaken.
Over a year ago, ServeTheHome.com tested running their entire website on Optane 900p SSDs, to see what difference it made. They reported that
We put copies of the entire STH main site on a dual Intel Xeon E5-2698 V4 system that is identical to another system we have set up in the hosting cluster save that this node had 2x Intel Optane 900p 280GB AICs, 2x Intel DC P3600 1.6TB NVMe AICs, and 2x Intel DC P3700 400GB 2.5″ SSDs.....
We [did] a second day entirely on the Intel Optane 900p 280GB SSDs [and tweeted] "The STH main site is being served via ZFS mirrored Intel Optane 900p NVMe SSDs for a few hours today just to generate some test data.."
— STH (@ServeTheHome) January 2, 2018
What's interesting in this post is a throwaway comment - the "v4" bit. The Xeon E5-2698 v4 is a Broadwell EP CPU (LGA 2011v3). From that alone, it's clear immediately that S.T.H. found Optane SSDs to be compatible enough, and stable enough, with Broadwell era CPUs, to serve their entire site during testing, and to gain very positive impressions on the combination as well.
People have even reported getting Optane to work on old Ivy Bridge 4790k motherboards running Windows 7 - suboptimally for sure, but clearly no fundamental hardware incompatibility.
tl;dr answer:
The limits on using Optane SSD like you'd use any other SSD, are apparently just the need for NVMe support (in the chipset+BIOS/UEFI+driver) and the lack of appropriate physical connectors, both of which are more likely to be missing as boards get older.
Very old versions of NVMe in the BIOS/UEFI might also need to be updated - there are hints about this in a couple of forum posts but no confirmation one way or the other so far.
- (Relevant and not-well-known resource: bios-mods.com is a website that specialises in updating bios firmware modules for NICs, SATA, RST, USB, etc to newer versions, so the boards can be used with newer hardware, drivers or OSes, it could be helpful if stuck)
The main reported issue in older chipsets/CPUs seems to be related to NVMe driver support (in Windows at least), which wasn't yet included in Intel RST at that time.
The requirement for a "latest CPU+chipset" only seems to apply if you want to use Intel's Optane-specific caching/acceleration/NVDIMM functionality, because that needs chipset support. But ordinary SSD use - apparently no issues.
add a comment |
It's now clear that Optane SSDs are 100% compatible with older chipsets and CPUs - guesses about CPU instruction sets are mistaken.
Over a year ago, ServeTheHome.com tested running their entire website on Optane 900p SSDs, to see what difference it made. They reported that
We put copies of the entire STH main site on a dual Intel Xeon E5-2698 V4 system that is identical to another system we have set up in the hosting cluster save that this node had 2x Intel Optane 900p 280GB AICs, 2x Intel DC P3600 1.6TB NVMe AICs, and 2x Intel DC P3700 400GB 2.5″ SSDs.....
We [did] a second day entirely on the Intel Optane 900p 280GB SSDs [and tweeted] "The STH main site is being served via ZFS mirrored Intel Optane 900p NVMe SSDs for a few hours today just to generate some test data.."
— STH (@ServeTheHome) January 2, 2018
What's interesting in this post is a throwaway comment - the "v4" bit. The Xeon E5-2698 v4 is a Broadwell EP CPU (LGA 2011v3). From that alone, it's clear immediately that S.T.H. found Optane SSDs to be compatible enough, and stable enough, with Broadwell era CPUs, to serve their entire site during testing, and to gain very positive impressions on the combination as well.
People have even reported getting Optane to work on old Ivy Bridge 4790k motherboards running Windows 7 - suboptimally for sure, but clearly no fundamental hardware incompatibility.
tl;dr answer:
The limits on using Optane SSD like you'd use any other SSD, are apparently just the need for NVMe support (in the chipset+BIOS/UEFI+driver) and the lack of appropriate physical connectors, both of which are more likely to be missing as boards get older.
Very old versions of NVMe in the BIOS/UEFI might also need to be updated - there are hints about this in a couple of forum posts but no confirmation one way or the other so far.
- (Relevant and not-well-known resource: bios-mods.com is a website that specialises in updating bios firmware modules for NICs, SATA, RST, USB, etc to newer versions, so the boards can be used with newer hardware, drivers or OSes, it could be helpful if stuck)
The main reported issue in older chipsets/CPUs seems to be related to NVMe driver support (in Windows at least), which wasn't yet included in Intel RST at that time.
The requirement for a "latest CPU+chipset" only seems to apply if you want to use Intel's Optane-specific caching/acceleration/NVDIMM functionality, because that needs chipset support. But ordinary SSD use - apparently no issues.
It's now clear that Optane SSDs are 100% compatible with older chipsets and CPUs - guesses about CPU instruction sets are mistaken.
Over a year ago, ServeTheHome.com tested running their entire website on Optane 900p SSDs, to see what difference it made. They reported that
We put copies of the entire STH main site on a dual Intel Xeon E5-2698 V4 system that is identical to another system we have set up in the hosting cluster save that this node had 2x Intel Optane 900p 280GB AICs, 2x Intel DC P3600 1.6TB NVMe AICs, and 2x Intel DC P3700 400GB 2.5″ SSDs.....
We [did] a second day entirely on the Intel Optane 900p 280GB SSDs [and tweeted] "The STH main site is being served via ZFS mirrored Intel Optane 900p NVMe SSDs for a few hours today just to generate some test data.."
— STH (@ServeTheHome) January 2, 2018
What's interesting in this post is a throwaway comment - the "v4" bit. The Xeon E5-2698 v4 is a Broadwell EP CPU (LGA 2011v3). From that alone, it's clear immediately that S.T.H. found Optane SSDs to be compatible enough, and stable enough, with Broadwell era CPUs, to serve their entire site during testing, and to gain very positive impressions on the combination as well.
People have even reported getting Optane to work on old Ivy Bridge 4790k motherboards running Windows 7 - suboptimally for sure, but clearly no fundamental hardware incompatibility.
tl;dr answer:
The limits on using Optane SSD like you'd use any other SSD, are apparently just the need for NVMe support (in the chipset+BIOS/UEFI+driver) and the lack of appropriate physical connectors, both of which are more likely to be missing as boards get older.
Very old versions of NVMe in the BIOS/UEFI might also need to be updated - there are hints about this in a couple of forum posts but no confirmation one way or the other so far.
- (Relevant and not-well-known resource: bios-mods.com is a website that specialises in updating bios firmware modules for NICs, SATA, RST, USB, etc to newer versions, so the boards can be used with newer hardware, drivers or OSes, it could be helpful if stuck)
The main reported issue in older chipsets/CPUs seems to be related to NVMe driver support (in Windows at least), which wasn't yet included in Intel RST at that time.
The requirement for a "latest CPU+chipset" only seems to apply if you want to use Intel's Optane-specific caching/acceleration/NVDIMM functionality, because that needs chipset support. But ordinary SSD use - apparently no issues.
edited Mar 5 at 11:45
answered Mar 3 at 19:16
StilezStilez
78011022
78011022
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Super User!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fsuperuser.com%2fquestions%2f1404980%2fare-optane-pcie-3-0-2282-cards-compatible-with-older-motherboards%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown