Sangaku: Show line segment is perpendicular to diameter of container circle











up vote
11
down vote

favorite
4












"From a 1803 Sangaku found in Gumma Prefecture. The base of an isosceles triangle sits on a diameter of the large circle. This diameter also bisects the circle on the left, which is inscribed so that it just touches the inside of the container circle and one vertex of the triangle. The top circle is inscribed so that it touches the outsides of both the left circle and the triangle, as well as the inside of the container circle. A line segment connects the center of the top circle and the intersection point between the left circle and the triangle. Show that this line segment is perpendicular to the drawn diameter of the container circle. (T. Rothman)"



enter image description here



Source: http://hermay.org/jconstant/wasan/sangaku/index.html



Enjoy!



EDIT



Note 1: The radius of the smaller circle touching the left vertex of the triangle is not necessarily half the radius of the enclosing circle. There IS variability in the base of the triangle.



Note 2: Two of the vertices of triangle necessarily are on the enclosing circle.










share|cite|improve this question
























  • I presume you don't want the use of coordinates here?
    – J. M. is not a mathematician
    Dec 22 '11 at 2:35










  • @J.M. - No coordinates. Synthetic proofs only.
    – dsg
    Dec 22 '11 at 3:19










  • Another presumption: The apex of the triangle lies on the circle. (The picture suggests this, but the description doesn't say so.) Otherwise, take the extreme case of a triangle with zero height and base equal to the big circle's radius; the top circle would be tangent to the diameter at a point somewhat to the right of center, so that the line joining the top circle's center the point of intersection (the big circle's center) would NOT be perpendicular to the diameter.
    – Blue
    Dec 22 '11 at 5:00










  • @Day: The triangle is isosceles. I was assuming that, regarding the apex lying on the circle, the text is authoritative and the diagram is misleading, since otherwise the problem would be rather trivial.
    – joriki
    Dec 22 '11 at 5:03










  • @joriki: But, then, what about my zero-height triangle counter-example? (And, regarding being trivial with the apex on the circle: is it? I agree that it would be if we knew that the the base took up exactly half of the diameter --as it seems in the diagram-- but we aren't guaranteed that ... and I'd think the triangle would've been described as equilateral in that case. The variability of the base seems to be what makes this problem interesting.)
    – Blue
    Dec 22 '11 at 5:14















up vote
11
down vote

favorite
4












"From a 1803 Sangaku found in Gumma Prefecture. The base of an isosceles triangle sits on a diameter of the large circle. This diameter also bisects the circle on the left, which is inscribed so that it just touches the inside of the container circle and one vertex of the triangle. The top circle is inscribed so that it touches the outsides of both the left circle and the triangle, as well as the inside of the container circle. A line segment connects the center of the top circle and the intersection point between the left circle and the triangle. Show that this line segment is perpendicular to the drawn diameter of the container circle. (T. Rothman)"



enter image description here



Source: http://hermay.org/jconstant/wasan/sangaku/index.html



Enjoy!



EDIT



Note 1: The radius of the smaller circle touching the left vertex of the triangle is not necessarily half the radius of the enclosing circle. There IS variability in the base of the triangle.



Note 2: Two of the vertices of triangle necessarily are on the enclosing circle.










share|cite|improve this question
























  • I presume you don't want the use of coordinates here?
    – J. M. is not a mathematician
    Dec 22 '11 at 2:35










  • @J.M. - No coordinates. Synthetic proofs only.
    – dsg
    Dec 22 '11 at 3:19










  • Another presumption: The apex of the triangle lies on the circle. (The picture suggests this, but the description doesn't say so.) Otherwise, take the extreme case of a triangle with zero height and base equal to the big circle's radius; the top circle would be tangent to the diameter at a point somewhat to the right of center, so that the line joining the top circle's center the point of intersection (the big circle's center) would NOT be perpendicular to the diameter.
    – Blue
    Dec 22 '11 at 5:00










  • @Day: The triangle is isosceles. I was assuming that, regarding the apex lying on the circle, the text is authoritative and the diagram is misleading, since otherwise the problem would be rather trivial.
    – joriki
    Dec 22 '11 at 5:03










  • @joriki: But, then, what about my zero-height triangle counter-example? (And, regarding being trivial with the apex on the circle: is it? I agree that it would be if we knew that the the base took up exactly half of the diameter --as it seems in the diagram-- but we aren't guaranteed that ... and I'd think the triangle would've been described as equilateral in that case. The variability of the base seems to be what makes this problem interesting.)
    – Blue
    Dec 22 '11 at 5:14













up vote
11
down vote

favorite
4









up vote
11
down vote

favorite
4






4





"From a 1803 Sangaku found in Gumma Prefecture. The base of an isosceles triangle sits on a diameter of the large circle. This diameter also bisects the circle on the left, which is inscribed so that it just touches the inside of the container circle and one vertex of the triangle. The top circle is inscribed so that it touches the outsides of both the left circle and the triangle, as well as the inside of the container circle. A line segment connects the center of the top circle and the intersection point between the left circle and the triangle. Show that this line segment is perpendicular to the drawn diameter of the container circle. (T. Rothman)"



enter image description here



Source: http://hermay.org/jconstant/wasan/sangaku/index.html



Enjoy!



EDIT



Note 1: The radius of the smaller circle touching the left vertex of the triangle is not necessarily half the radius of the enclosing circle. There IS variability in the base of the triangle.



Note 2: Two of the vertices of triangle necessarily are on the enclosing circle.










share|cite|improve this question















"From a 1803 Sangaku found in Gumma Prefecture. The base of an isosceles triangle sits on a diameter of the large circle. This diameter also bisects the circle on the left, which is inscribed so that it just touches the inside of the container circle and one vertex of the triangle. The top circle is inscribed so that it touches the outsides of both the left circle and the triangle, as well as the inside of the container circle. A line segment connects the center of the top circle and the intersection point between the left circle and the triangle. Show that this line segment is perpendicular to the drawn diameter of the container circle. (T. Rothman)"



enter image description here



Source: http://hermay.org/jconstant/wasan/sangaku/index.html



Enjoy!



EDIT



Note 1: The radius of the smaller circle touching the left vertex of the triangle is not necessarily half the radius of the enclosing circle. There IS variability in the base of the triangle.



Note 2: Two of the vertices of triangle necessarily are on the enclosing circle.







geometry euclidean-geometry triangle circle sangaku






share|cite|improve this question















share|cite|improve this question













share|cite|improve this question




share|cite|improve this question








edited Nov 22 at 21:01









Jean-Claude Arbaut

14.7k63363




14.7k63363










asked Dec 22 '11 at 1:52









dsg

6311618




6311618












  • I presume you don't want the use of coordinates here?
    – J. M. is not a mathematician
    Dec 22 '11 at 2:35










  • @J.M. - No coordinates. Synthetic proofs only.
    – dsg
    Dec 22 '11 at 3:19










  • Another presumption: The apex of the triangle lies on the circle. (The picture suggests this, but the description doesn't say so.) Otherwise, take the extreme case of a triangle with zero height and base equal to the big circle's radius; the top circle would be tangent to the diameter at a point somewhat to the right of center, so that the line joining the top circle's center the point of intersection (the big circle's center) would NOT be perpendicular to the diameter.
    – Blue
    Dec 22 '11 at 5:00










  • @Day: The triangle is isosceles. I was assuming that, regarding the apex lying on the circle, the text is authoritative and the diagram is misleading, since otherwise the problem would be rather trivial.
    – joriki
    Dec 22 '11 at 5:03










  • @joriki: But, then, what about my zero-height triangle counter-example? (And, regarding being trivial with the apex on the circle: is it? I agree that it would be if we knew that the the base took up exactly half of the diameter --as it seems in the diagram-- but we aren't guaranteed that ... and I'd think the triangle would've been described as equilateral in that case. The variability of the base seems to be what makes this problem interesting.)
    – Blue
    Dec 22 '11 at 5:14


















  • I presume you don't want the use of coordinates here?
    – J. M. is not a mathematician
    Dec 22 '11 at 2:35










  • @J.M. - No coordinates. Synthetic proofs only.
    – dsg
    Dec 22 '11 at 3:19










  • Another presumption: The apex of the triangle lies on the circle. (The picture suggests this, but the description doesn't say so.) Otherwise, take the extreme case of a triangle with zero height and base equal to the big circle's radius; the top circle would be tangent to the diameter at a point somewhat to the right of center, so that the line joining the top circle's center the point of intersection (the big circle's center) would NOT be perpendicular to the diameter.
    – Blue
    Dec 22 '11 at 5:00










  • @Day: The triangle is isosceles. I was assuming that, regarding the apex lying on the circle, the text is authoritative and the diagram is misleading, since otherwise the problem would be rather trivial.
    – joriki
    Dec 22 '11 at 5:03










  • @joriki: But, then, what about my zero-height triangle counter-example? (And, regarding being trivial with the apex on the circle: is it? I agree that it would be if we knew that the the base took up exactly half of the diameter --as it seems in the diagram-- but we aren't guaranteed that ... and I'd think the triangle would've been described as equilateral in that case. The variability of the base seems to be what makes this problem interesting.)
    – Blue
    Dec 22 '11 at 5:14
















I presume you don't want the use of coordinates here?
– J. M. is not a mathematician
Dec 22 '11 at 2:35




I presume you don't want the use of coordinates here?
– J. M. is not a mathematician
Dec 22 '11 at 2:35












@J.M. - No coordinates. Synthetic proofs only.
– dsg
Dec 22 '11 at 3:19




@J.M. - No coordinates. Synthetic proofs only.
– dsg
Dec 22 '11 at 3:19












Another presumption: The apex of the triangle lies on the circle. (The picture suggests this, but the description doesn't say so.) Otherwise, take the extreme case of a triangle with zero height and base equal to the big circle's radius; the top circle would be tangent to the diameter at a point somewhat to the right of center, so that the line joining the top circle's center the point of intersection (the big circle's center) would NOT be perpendicular to the diameter.
– Blue
Dec 22 '11 at 5:00




Another presumption: The apex of the triangle lies on the circle. (The picture suggests this, but the description doesn't say so.) Otherwise, take the extreme case of a triangle with zero height and base equal to the big circle's radius; the top circle would be tangent to the diameter at a point somewhat to the right of center, so that the line joining the top circle's center the point of intersection (the big circle's center) would NOT be perpendicular to the diameter.
– Blue
Dec 22 '11 at 5:00












@Day: The triangle is isosceles. I was assuming that, regarding the apex lying on the circle, the text is authoritative and the diagram is misleading, since otherwise the problem would be rather trivial.
– joriki
Dec 22 '11 at 5:03




@Day: The triangle is isosceles. I was assuming that, regarding the apex lying on the circle, the text is authoritative and the diagram is misleading, since otherwise the problem would be rather trivial.
– joriki
Dec 22 '11 at 5:03












@joriki: But, then, what about my zero-height triangle counter-example? (And, regarding being trivial with the apex on the circle: is it? I agree that it would be if we knew that the the base took up exactly half of the diameter --as it seems in the diagram-- but we aren't guaranteed that ... and I'd think the triangle would've been described as equilateral in that case. The variability of the base seems to be what makes this problem interesting.)
– Blue
Dec 22 '11 at 5:14




@joriki: But, then, what about my zero-height triangle counter-example? (And, regarding being trivial with the apex on the circle: is it? I agree that it would be if we knew that the the base took up exactly half of the diameter --as it seems in the diagram-- but we aren't guaranteed that ... and I'd think the triangle would've been described as equilateral in that case. The variability of the base seems to be what makes this problem interesting.)
– Blue
Dec 22 '11 at 5:14










2 Answers
2






active

oldest

votes

















up vote
1
down vote



accepted










For those who do not like inversion... =P



Let $A$ be the big circle with centre $O$ and diameter $PQ$

Let $B$ be the circle internally tangent to $A$ at $P$ and intersecting $PQ$ again at $M$ and having centre $J$

Let $R$ be on $A$ such that $overline{MR} = overline{QR}$

Let $C$ be the circle that is tangent to $A$, $B$, $MR$ and inside $A$ and outside both $B$ and completely on the same side of $PQ$ as $R$

Let $K$ be the point on $MQ$ such that $RK perp MQ$

Let $D$ be the circle tangent to $B$ and $MR$ with centre $N$ such that $PQ perp MN$ and $N$,$R$ are on the same side of $PQ$

Let $Z$ be the point where $D$ is tangent to $MR$

Let $overrightarrow{MO} = r overrightarrow{OQ}$ and WLOG $overline{OQ} = 1$

Let $x = overline{MN}$

Let $y$ be the radius of $D$

Then $overline{MR}^2 = overline{RK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = overline{OR}^2 - overline{OK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = 1 - (frac{1-r}{2})^2 + (frac{1+r}{2})^2 = 1+r$

Since $triangle MNZ sim triangle RMK$, $frac{x}{y} = overline{MN} / overline{NZ} = overline{RM} / overline{MK} = sqrt{1+r} / frac{1+r}{2} = frac{2}{sqrt{1+r}}$

Thus $(1+r)x^2 = 4y^2$

Also $(y+frac{1-r}{2})^2 = overline{NJ}^2 = overline{MN}^2 + overline{MJ}^2 = (frac{1-r}{2})^2 + x^2$

Thus $(1+r)y^2 + (1+r)(1-r)y = (1+r)x^2 = 4y^2$

Since $ynot=0$, $(3-r)y = 1-r^2$

$overline{OQ} = y + overline{ON}$

$Leftrightarrow (1-y)^2 = overline{ON}^2 = overline{MN}^2 + overline{MO}^2 = x^2 + r^2$

$Leftrightarrow (1+r)(1-2y+y^2) = 4y^2 + (1+r)r^2$

$Leftrightarrow (3-r)y^2 + (2+2r)y - (1+r)(1-r^2) = 0$

$Leftrightarrow (1-r^2)y + (2+2r)y = (1+r)(1-r^2)$

$Leftrightarrow (1+r)(3-r)y = (1+r)(1-r^2)$ which is clearly true

Thus $D$ is tangent to $A$

Since $C$ is uniquely defined and $D$ is an identically defined circle, $N$ is the centre of $C$

Therefore the line through both $M$ and the centre of $C$ is perpendicular to $PQ$

(QED)






share|cite|improve this answer




























    up vote
    2
    down vote













    Let $A$ be the big circle with centre $O$ and diameter $PQ$

    Let $B$ be the circle internally tangent to $A$ at $P$ and intersecting $PQ$ again at $M$

    Let $R$ be on $A$ such that $overline{MR} = overline{QR}$

    Let $C$ be the circle that is tangent to $A$, $B$, $MR$ and inside $A$ and outside both $B$ and completely on the same side of $PQ$ as $R$
    Invert at $M$, mapping $P$ to $Q$

    Then $A$ maps to $A$, $B$ maps to the line $T$ that is tangent to $B$ at $Q$, $MR$ maps to $MR$, and thus $C$ maps to the circle $D$ that is tangent to $A$, $T$, $MR$ and outside $A$ and on the same side of $T$ as $M$ and completely on the other side of $PQ$ as $R$

    Let $K$ be the point on $MQ$ such that $RK perp MQ$

    Let $N$ be the point such that $PQ perp MN$ and $overline{MN} = 2overline{MR}$ and $N$, $R$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$

    Let $X$ be the intersection of $NO$ and $A$ between $N$ and $O$

    Let $Y$ be the point on $T$ such that $NY perp T$

    Let $Z$ be the point on $MR$ such that $NZ perp MR$

    Let $overrightarrow{MO} = r overrightarrow{OQ}$ and WLOG $overline{OQ} = 1$

    Then $overline{MR}^2 = overline{RK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = overline{OR}^2 - overline{OK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = 1 - (frac{1-r}{2})^2 + (frac{1+r}{2})^2 = 1+r$

    Thus $overline{NO}^2 = overline{MN}^2 + r^2 = 4 overline{MR}^2 + r^2 = 4+4r+r^2 = (2+r)^2$

    Thus $overline{NX} = (2+r)-1 = overline{MQ}$

    Also it is clear that $overline{NY} = overline{MQ}$

    Also since $triangle MNZ sim triangle RMK$, $overline{NZ} = 2 overline{MK} = overline{MQ}$

    Since $D$ is uniquely defined and $N$ is the centre of an identically defined circle, $N$ is the centre of $D$

    Since the centres of $C$ and $D$ are collinear with $M$, the centre of $C$ lies on $MN$, therefore the line through both $M$ and the centre of $C$ is perpendicular to $PQ$

    (QED)



    Note that the same solution applies to both cases where $C$ is on either side of $PQ$, with very minor changes. Inversion seems to simplify most of these kind of questions. Quite a few can be found online.






    share|cite|improve this answer























    • What do you mean by "$N$, $B$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$"? The circle $B$ is on both sides of $PQ$.
      – Rahul
      Dec 29 '11 at 12:16










    • @Rahul: It should read "$N$,$R$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$". I have corrected the error in my solution. Thanks!
      – user21820
      Dec 29 '11 at 12:44











    Your Answer





    StackExchange.ifUsing("editor", function () {
    return StackExchange.using("mathjaxEditing", function () {
    StackExchange.MarkdownEditor.creationCallbacks.add(function (editor, postfix) {
    StackExchange.mathjaxEditing.prepareWmdForMathJax(editor, postfix, [["$", "$"], ["\\(","\\)"]]);
    });
    });
    }, "mathjax-editing");

    StackExchange.ready(function() {
    var channelOptions = {
    tags: "".split(" "),
    id: "69"
    };
    initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

    StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
    // Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
    if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
    StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
    createEditor();
    });
    }
    else {
    createEditor();
    }
    });

    function createEditor() {
    StackExchange.prepareEditor({
    heartbeatType: 'answer',
    convertImagesToLinks: true,
    noModals: true,
    showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
    reputationToPostImages: 10,
    bindNavPrevention: true,
    postfix: "",
    imageUploader: {
    brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
    contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
    allowUrls: true
    },
    noCode: true, onDemand: true,
    discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
    ,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
    });


    }
    });














    draft saved

    draft discarded


















    StackExchange.ready(
    function () {
    StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f93353%2fsangaku-show-line-segment-is-perpendicular-to-diameter-of-container-circle%23new-answer', 'question_page');
    }
    );

    Post as a guest















    Required, but never shown

























    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes








    2 Answers
    2






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes








    up vote
    1
    down vote



    accepted










    For those who do not like inversion... =P



    Let $A$ be the big circle with centre $O$ and diameter $PQ$

    Let $B$ be the circle internally tangent to $A$ at $P$ and intersecting $PQ$ again at $M$ and having centre $J$

    Let $R$ be on $A$ such that $overline{MR} = overline{QR}$

    Let $C$ be the circle that is tangent to $A$, $B$, $MR$ and inside $A$ and outside both $B$ and completely on the same side of $PQ$ as $R$

    Let $K$ be the point on $MQ$ such that $RK perp MQ$

    Let $D$ be the circle tangent to $B$ and $MR$ with centre $N$ such that $PQ perp MN$ and $N$,$R$ are on the same side of $PQ$

    Let $Z$ be the point where $D$ is tangent to $MR$

    Let $overrightarrow{MO} = r overrightarrow{OQ}$ and WLOG $overline{OQ} = 1$

    Let $x = overline{MN}$

    Let $y$ be the radius of $D$

    Then $overline{MR}^2 = overline{RK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = overline{OR}^2 - overline{OK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = 1 - (frac{1-r}{2})^2 + (frac{1+r}{2})^2 = 1+r$

    Since $triangle MNZ sim triangle RMK$, $frac{x}{y} = overline{MN} / overline{NZ} = overline{RM} / overline{MK} = sqrt{1+r} / frac{1+r}{2} = frac{2}{sqrt{1+r}}$

    Thus $(1+r)x^2 = 4y^2$

    Also $(y+frac{1-r}{2})^2 = overline{NJ}^2 = overline{MN}^2 + overline{MJ}^2 = (frac{1-r}{2})^2 + x^2$

    Thus $(1+r)y^2 + (1+r)(1-r)y = (1+r)x^2 = 4y^2$

    Since $ynot=0$, $(3-r)y = 1-r^2$

    $overline{OQ} = y + overline{ON}$

    $Leftrightarrow (1-y)^2 = overline{ON}^2 = overline{MN}^2 + overline{MO}^2 = x^2 + r^2$

    $Leftrightarrow (1+r)(1-2y+y^2) = 4y^2 + (1+r)r^2$

    $Leftrightarrow (3-r)y^2 + (2+2r)y - (1+r)(1-r^2) = 0$

    $Leftrightarrow (1-r^2)y + (2+2r)y = (1+r)(1-r^2)$

    $Leftrightarrow (1+r)(3-r)y = (1+r)(1-r^2)$ which is clearly true

    Thus $D$ is tangent to $A$

    Since $C$ is uniquely defined and $D$ is an identically defined circle, $N$ is the centre of $C$

    Therefore the line through both $M$ and the centre of $C$ is perpendicular to $PQ$

    (QED)






    share|cite|improve this answer

























      up vote
      1
      down vote



      accepted










      For those who do not like inversion... =P



      Let $A$ be the big circle with centre $O$ and diameter $PQ$

      Let $B$ be the circle internally tangent to $A$ at $P$ and intersecting $PQ$ again at $M$ and having centre $J$

      Let $R$ be on $A$ such that $overline{MR} = overline{QR}$

      Let $C$ be the circle that is tangent to $A$, $B$, $MR$ and inside $A$ and outside both $B$ and completely on the same side of $PQ$ as $R$

      Let $K$ be the point on $MQ$ such that $RK perp MQ$

      Let $D$ be the circle tangent to $B$ and $MR$ with centre $N$ such that $PQ perp MN$ and $N$,$R$ are on the same side of $PQ$

      Let $Z$ be the point where $D$ is tangent to $MR$

      Let $overrightarrow{MO} = r overrightarrow{OQ}$ and WLOG $overline{OQ} = 1$

      Let $x = overline{MN}$

      Let $y$ be the radius of $D$

      Then $overline{MR}^2 = overline{RK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = overline{OR}^2 - overline{OK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = 1 - (frac{1-r}{2})^2 + (frac{1+r}{2})^2 = 1+r$

      Since $triangle MNZ sim triangle RMK$, $frac{x}{y} = overline{MN} / overline{NZ} = overline{RM} / overline{MK} = sqrt{1+r} / frac{1+r}{2} = frac{2}{sqrt{1+r}}$

      Thus $(1+r)x^2 = 4y^2$

      Also $(y+frac{1-r}{2})^2 = overline{NJ}^2 = overline{MN}^2 + overline{MJ}^2 = (frac{1-r}{2})^2 + x^2$

      Thus $(1+r)y^2 + (1+r)(1-r)y = (1+r)x^2 = 4y^2$

      Since $ynot=0$, $(3-r)y = 1-r^2$

      $overline{OQ} = y + overline{ON}$

      $Leftrightarrow (1-y)^2 = overline{ON}^2 = overline{MN}^2 + overline{MO}^2 = x^2 + r^2$

      $Leftrightarrow (1+r)(1-2y+y^2) = 4y^2 + (1+r)r^2$

      $Leftrightarrow (3-r)y^2 + (2+2r)y - (1+r)(1-r^2) = 0$

      $Leftrightarrow (1-r^2)y + (2+2r)y = (1+r)(1-r^2)$

      $Leftrightarrow (1+r)(3-r)y = (1+r)(1-r^2)$ which is clearly true

      Thus $D$ is tangent to $A$

      Since $C$ is uniquely defined and $D$ is an identically defined circle, $N$ is the centre of $C$

      Therefore the line through both $M$ and the centre of $C$ is perpendicular to $PQ$

      (QED)






      share|cite|improve this answer























        up vote
        1
        down vote



        accepted







        up vote
        1
        down vote



        accepted






        For those who do not like inversion... =P



        Let $A$ be the big circle with centre $O$ and diameter $PQ$

        Let $B$ be the circle internally tangent to $A$ at $P$ and intersecting $PQ$ again at $M$ and having centre $J$

        Let $R$ be on $A$ such that $overline{MR} = overline{QR}$

        Let $C$ be the circle that is tangent to $A$, $B$, $MR$ and inside $A$ and outside both $B$ and completely on the same side of $PQ$ as $R$

        Let $K$ be the point on $MQ$ such that $RK perp MQ$

        Let $D$ be the circle tangent to $B$ and $MR$ with centre $N$ such that $PQ perp MN$ and $N$,$R$ are on the same side of $PQ$

        Let $Z$ be the point where $D$ is tangent to $MR$

        Let $overrightarrow{MO} = r overrightarrow{OQ}$ and WLOG $overline{OQ} = 1$

        Let $x = overline{MN}$

        Let $y$ be the radius of $D$

        Then $overline{MR}^2 = overline{RK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = overline{OR}^2 - overline{OK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = 1 - (frac{1-r}{2})^2 + (frac{1+r}{2})^2 = 1+r$

        Since $triangle MNZ sim triangle RMK$, $frac{x}{y} = overline{MN} / overline{NZ} = overline{RM} / overline{MK} = sqrt{1+r} / frac{1+r}{2} = frac{2}{sqrt{1+r}}$

        Thus $(1+r)x^2 = 4y^2$

        Also $(y+frac{1-r}{2})^2 = overline{NJ}^2 = overline{MN}^2 + overline{MJ}^2 = (frac{1-r}{2})^2 + x^2$

        Thus $(1+r)y^2 + (1+r)(1-r)y = (1+r)x^2 = 4y^2$

        Since $ynot=0$, $(3-r)y = 1-r^2$

        $overline{OQ} = y + overline{ON}$

        $Leftrightarrow (1-y)^2 = overline{ON}^2 = overline{MN}^2 + overline{MO}^2 = x^2 + r^2$

        $Leftrightarrow (1+r)(1-2y+y^2) = 4y^2 + (1+r)r^2$

        $Leftrightarrow (3-r)y^2 + (2+2r)y - (1+r)(1-r^2) = 0$

        $Leftrightarrow (1-r^2)y + (2+2r)y = (1+r)(1-r^2)$

        $Leftrightarrow (1+r)(3-r)y = (1+r)(1-r^2)$ which is clearly true

        Thus $D$ is tangent to $A$

        Since $C$ is uniquely defined and $D$ is an identically defined circle, $N$ is the centre of $C$

        Therefore the line through both $M$ and the centre of $C$ is perpendicular to $PQ$

        (QED)






        share|cite|improve this answer












        For those who do not like inversion... =P



        Let $A$ be the big circle with centre $O$ and diameter $PQ$

        Let $B$ be the circle internally tangent to $A$ at $P$ and intersecting $PQ$ again at $M$ and having centre $J$

        Let $R$ be on $A$ such that $overline{MR} = overline{QR}$

        Let $C$ be the circle that is tangent to $A$, $B$, $MR$ and inside $A$ and outside both $B$ and completely on the same side of $PQ$ as $R$

        Let $K$ be the point on $MQ$ such that $RK perp MQ$

        Let $D$ be the circle tangent to $B$ and $MR$ with centre $N$ such that $PQ perp MN$ and $N$,$R$ are on the same side of $PQ$

        Let $Z$ be the point where $D$ is tangent to $MR$

        Let $overrightarrow{MO} = r overrightarrow{OQ}$ and WLOG $overline{OQ} = 1$

        Let $x = overline{MN}$

        Let $y$ be the radius of $D$

        Then $overline{MR}^2 = overline{RK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = overline{OR}^2 - overline{OK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = 1 - (frac{1-r}{2})^2 + (frac{1+r}{2})^2 = 1+r$

        Since $triangle MNZ sim triangle RMK$, $frac{x}{y} = overline{MN} / overline{NZ} = overline{RM} / overline{MK} = sqrt{1+r} / frac{1+r}{2} = frac{2}{sqrt{1+r}}$

        Thus $(1+r)x^2 = 4y^2$

        Also $(y+frac{1-r}{2})^2 = overline{NJ}^2 = overline{MN}^2 + overline{MJ}^2 = (frac{1-r}{2})^2 + x^2$

        Thus $(1+r)y^2 + (1+r)(1-r)y = (1+r)x^2 = 4y^2$

        Since $ynot=0$, $(3-r)y = 1-r^2$

        $overline{OQ} = y + overline{ON}$

        $Leftrightarrow (1-y)^2 = overline{ON}^2 = overline{MN}^2 + overline{MO}^2 = x^2 + r^2$

        $Leftrightarrow (1+r)(1-2y+y^2) = 4y^2 + (1+r)r^2$

        $Leftrightarrow (3-r)y^2 + (2+2r)y - (1+r)(1-r^2) = 0$

        $Leftrightarrow (1-r^2)y + (2+2r)y = (1+r)(1-r^2)$

        $Leftrightarrow (1+r)(3-r)y = (1+r)(1-r^2)$ which is clearly true

        Thus $D$ is tangent to $A$

        Since $C$ is uniquely defined and $D$ is an identically defined circle, $N$ is the centre of $C$

        Therefore the line through both $M$ and the centre of $C$ is perpendicular to $PQ$

        (QED)







        share|cite|improve this answer












        share|cite|improve this answer



        share|cite|improve this answer










        answered Dec 29 '11 at 12:40









        user21820

        38.2k541151




        38.2k541151






















            up vote
            2
            down vote













            Let $A$ be the big circle with centre $O$ and diameter $PQ$

            Let $B$ be the circle internally tangent to $A$ at $P$ and intersecting $PQ$ again at $M$

            Let $R$ be on $A$ such that $overline{MR} = overline{QR}$

            Let $C$ be the circle that is tangent to $A$, $B$, $MR$ and inside $A$ and outside both $B$ and completely on the same side of $PQ$ as $R$
            Invert at $M$, mapping $P$ to $Q$

            Then $A$ maps to $A$, $B$ maps to the line $T$ that is tangent to $B$ at $Q$, $MR$ maps to $MR$, and thus $C$ maps to the circle $D$ that is tangent to $A$, $T$, $MR$ and outside $A$ and on the same side of $T$ as $M$ and completely on the other side of $PQ$ as $R$

            Let $K$ be the point on $MQ$ such that $RK perp MQ$

            Let $N$ be the point such that $PQ perp MN$ and $overline{MN} = 2overline{MR}$ and $N$, $R$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$

            Let $X$ be the intersection of $NO$ and $A$ between $N$ and $O$

            Let $Y$ be the point on $T$ such that $NY perp T$

            Let $Z$ be the point on $MR$ such that $NZ perp MR$

            Let $overrightarrow{MO} = r overrightarrow{OQ}$ and WLOG $overline{OQ} = 1$

            Then $overline{MR}^2 = overline{RK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = overline{OR}^2 - overline{OK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = 1 - (frac{1-r}{2})^2 + (frac{1+r}{2})^2 = 1+r$

            Thus $overline{NO}^2 = overline{MN}^2 + r^2 = 4 overline{MR}^2 + r^2 = 4+4r+r^2 = (2+r)^2$

            Thus $overline{NX} = (2+r)-1 = overline{MQ}$

            Also it is clear that $overline{NY} = overline{MQ}$

            Also since $triangle MNZ sim triangle RMK$, $overline{NZ} = 2 overline{MK} = overline{MQ}$

            Since $D$ is uniquely defined and $N$ is the centre of an identically defined circle, $N$ is the centre of $D$

            Since the centres of $C$ and $D$ are collinear with $M$, the centre of $C$ lies on $MN$, therefore the line through both $M$ and the centre of $C$ is perpendicular to $PQ$

            (QED)



            Note that the same solution applies to both cases where $C$ is on either side of $PQ$, with very minor changes. Inversion seems to simplify most of these kind of questions. Quite a few can be found online.






            share|cite|improve this answer























            • What do you mean by "$N$, $B$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$"? The circle $B$ is on both sides of $PQ$.
              – Rahul
              Dec 29 '11 at 12:16










            • @Rahul: It should read "$N$,$R$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$". I have corrected the error in my solution. Thanks!
              – user21820
              Dec 29 '11 at 12:44















            up vote
            2
            down vote













            Let $A$ be the big circle with centre $O$ and diameter $PQ$

            Let $B$ be the circle internally tangent to $A$ at $P$ and intersecting $PQ$ again at $M$

            Let $R$ be on $A$ such that $overline{MR} = overline{QR}$

            Let $C$ be the circle that is tangent to $A$, $B$, $MR$ and inside $A$ and outside both $B$ and completely on the same side of $PQ$ as $R$
            Invert at $M$, mapping $P$ to $Q$

            Then $A$ maps to $A$, $B$ maps to the line $T$ that is tangent to $B$ at $Q$, $MR$ maps to $MR$, and thus $C$ maps to the circle $D$ that is tangent to $A$, $T$, $MR$ and outside $A$ and on the same side of $T$ as $M$ and completely on the other side of $PQ$ as $R$

            Let $K$ be the point on $MQ$ such that $RK perp MQ$

            Let $N$ be the point such that $PQ perp MN$ and $overline{MN} = 2overline{MR}$ and $N$, $R$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$

            Let $X$ be the intersection of $NO$ and $A$ between $N$ and $O$

            Let $Y$ be the point on $T$ such that $NY perp T$

            Let $Z$ be the point on $MR$ such that $NZ perp MR$

            Let $overrightarrow{MO} = r overrightarrow{OQ}$ and WLOG $overline{OQ} = 1$

            Then $overline{MR}^2 = overline{RK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = overline{OR}^2 - overline{OK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = 1 - (frac{1-r}{2})^2 + (frac{1+r}{2})^2 = 1+r$

            Thus $overline{NO}^2 = overline{MN}^2 + r^2 = 4 overline{MR}^2 + r^2 = 4+4r+r^2 = (2+r)^2$

            Thus $overline{NX} = (2+r)-1 = overline{MQ}$

            Also it is clear that $overline{NY} = overline{MQ}$

            Also since $triangle MNZ sim triangle RMK$, $overline{NZ} = 2 overline{MK} = overline{MQ}$

            Since $D$ is uniquely defined and $N$ is the centre of an identically defined circle, $N$ is the centre of $D$

            Since the centres of $C$ and $D$ are collinear with $M$, the centre of $C$ lies on $MN$, therefore the line through both $M$ and the centre of $C$ is perpendicular to $PQ$

            (QED)



            Note that the same solution applies to both cases where $C$ is on either side of $PQ$, with very minor changes. Inversion seems to simplify most of these kind of questions. Quite a few can be found online.






            share|cite|improve this answer























            • What do you mean by "$N$, $B$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$"? The circle $B$ is on both sides of $PQ$.
              – Rahul
              Dec 29 '11 at 12:16










            • @Rahul: It should read "$N$,$R$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$". I have corrected the error in my solution. Thanks!
              – user21820
              Dec 29 '11 at 12:44













            up vote
            2
            down vote










            up vote
            2
            down vote









            Let $A$ be the big circle with centre $O$ and diameter $PQ$

            Let $B$ be the circle internally tangent to $A$ at $P$ and intersecting $PQ$ again at $M$

            Let $R$ be on $A$ such that $overline{MR} = overline{QR}$

            Let $C$ be the circle that is tangent to $A$, $B$, $MR$ and inside $A$ and outside both $B$ and completely on the same side of $PQ$ as $R$
            Invert at $M$, mapping $P$ to $Q$

            Then $A$ maps to $A$, $B$ maps to the line $T$ that is tangent to $B$ at $Q$, $MR$ maps to $MR$, and thus $C$ maps to the circle $D$ that is tangent to $A$, $T$, $MR$ and outside $A$ and on the same side of $T$ as $M$ and completely on the other side of $PQ$ as $R$

            Let $K$ be the point on $MQ$ such that $RK perp MQ$

            Let $N$ be the point such that $PQ perp MN$ and $overline{MN} = 2overline{MR}$ and $N$, $R$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$

            Let $X$ be the intersection of $NO$ and $A$ between $N$ and $O$

            Let $Y$ be the point on $T$ such that $NY perp T$

            Let $Z$ be the point on $MR$ such that $NZ perp MR$

            Let $overrightarrow{MO} = r overrightarrow{OQ}$ and WLOG $overline{OQ} = 1$

            Then $overline{MR}^2 = overline{RK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = overline{OR}^2 - overline{OK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = 1 - (frac{1-r}{2})^2 + (frac{1+r}{2})^2 = 1+r$

            Thus $overline{NO}^2 = overline{MN}^2 + r^2 = 4 overline{MR}^2 + r^2 = 4+4r+r^2 = (2+r)^2$

            Thus $overline{NX} = (2+r)-1 = overline{MQ}$

            Also it is clear that $overline{NY} = overline{MQ}$

            Also since $triangle MNZ sim triangle RMK$, $overline{NZ} = 2 overline{MK} = overline{MQ}$

            Since $D$ is uniquely defined and $N$ is the centre of an identically defined circle, $N$ is the centre of $D$

            Since the centres of $C$ and $D$ are collinear with $M$, the centre of $C$ lies on $MN$, therefore the line through both $M$ and the centre of $C$ is perpendicular to $PQ$

            (QED)



            Note that the same solution applies to both cases where $C$ is on either side of $PQ$, with very minor changes. Inversion seems to simplify most of these kind of questions. Quite a few can be found online.






            share|cite|improve this answer














            Let $A$ be the big circle with centre $O$ and diameter $PQ$

            Let $B$ be the circle internally tangent to $A$ at $P$ and intersecting $PQ$ again at $M$

            Let $R$ be on $A$ such that $overline{MR} = overline{QR}$

            Let $C$ be the circle that is tangent to $A$, $B$, $MR$ and inside $A$ and outside both $B$ and completely on the same side of $PQ$ as $R$
            Invert at $M$, mapping $P$ to $Q$

            Then $A$ maps to $A$, $B$ maps to the line $T$ that is tangent to $B$ at $Q$, $MR$ maps to $MR$, and thus $C$ maps to the circle $D$ that is tangent to $A$, $T$, $MR$ and outside $A$ and on the same side of $T$ as $M$ and completely on the other side of $PQ$ as $R$

            Let $K$ be the point on $MQ$ such that $RK perp MQ$

            Let $N$ be the point such that $PQ perp MN$ and $overline{MN} = 2overline{MR}$ and $N$, $R$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$

            Let $X$ be the intersection of $NO$ and $A$ between $N$ and $O$

            Let $Y$ be the point on $T$ such that $NY perp T$

            Let $Z$ be the point on $MR$ such that $NZ perp MR$

            Let $overrightarrow{MO} = r overrightarrow{OQ}$ and WLOG $overline{OQ} = 1$

            Then $overline{MR}^2 = overline{RK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = overline{OR}^2 - overline{OK}^2 + overline{MK}^2 = 1 - (frac{1-r}{2})^2 + (frac{1+r}{2})^2 = 1+r$

            Thus $overline{NO}^2 = overline{MN}^2 + r^2 = 4 overline{MR}^2 + r^2 = 4+4r+r^2 = (2+r)^2$

            Thus $overline{NX} = (2+r)-1 = overline{MQ}$

            Also it is clear that $overline{NY} = overline{MQ}$

            Also since $triangle MNZ sim triangle RMK$, $overline{NZ} = 2 overline{MK} = overline{MQ}$

            Since $D$ is uniquely defined and $N$ is the centre of an identically defined circle, $N$ is the centre of $D$

            Since the centres of $C$ and $D$ are collinear with $M$, the centre of $C$ lies on $MN$, therefore the line through both $M$ and the centre of $C$ is perpendicular to $PQ$

            (QED)



            Note that the same solution applies to both cases where $C$ is on either side of $PQ$, with very minor changes. Inversion seems to simplify most of these kind of questions. Quite a few can be found online.







            share|cite|improve this answer














            share|cite|improve this answer



            share|cite|improve this answer








            edited Dec 29 '11 at 12:43

























            answered Dec 27 '11 at 12:08









            user21820

            38.2k541151




            38.2k541151












            • What do you mean by "$N$, $B$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$"? The circle $B$ is on both sides of $PQ$.
              – Rahul
              Dec 29 '11 at 12:16










            • @Rahul: It should read "$N$,$R$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$". I have corrected the error in my solution. Thanks!
              – user21820
              Dec 29 '11 at 12:44


















            • What do you mean by "$N$, $B$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$"? The circle $B$ is on both sides of $PQ$.
              – Rahul
              Dec 29 '11 at 12:16










            • @Rahul: It should read "$N$,$R$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$". I have corrected the error in my solution. Thanks!
              – user21820
              Dec 29 '11 at 12:44
















            What do you mean by "$N$, $B$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$"? The circle $B$ is on both sides of $PQ$.
            – Rahul
            Dec 29 '11 at 12:16




            What do you mean by "$N$, $B$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$"? The circle $B$ is on both sides of $PQ$.
            – Rahul
            Dec 29 '11 at 12:16












            @Rahul: It should read "$N$,$R$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$". I have corrected the error in my solution. Thanks!
            – user21820
            Dec 29 '11 at 12:44




            @Rahul: It should read "$N$,$R$ are on the opposite side of $PQ$". I have corrected the error in my solution. Thanks!
            – user21820
            Dec 29 '11 at 12:44


















            draft saved

            draft discarded




















































            Thanks for contributing an answer to Mathematics Stack Exchange!


            • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

            But avoid



            • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

            • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


            Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.


            To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.





            Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.


            Please pay close attention to the following guidance:


            • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

            But avoid



            • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

            • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


            To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




            draft saved


            draft discarded














            StackExchange.ready(
            function () {
            StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f93353%2fsangaku-show-line-segment-is-perpendicular-to-diameter-of-container-circle%23new-answer', 'question_page');
            }
            );

            Post as a guest















            Required, but never shown





















































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown

































            Required, but never shown














            Required, but never shown












            Required, but never shown







            Required, but never shown







            Popular posts from this blog

            How do I know what Microsoft account the skydrive app is syncing to?

            When does type information flow backwards in C++?

            Grease: Live!